OT Are all heating engineers touchy?

Jul 09, 2013 49 Replies
Saved reading

Which is fair enough modern boilers are rather complex beasts compared to a lump of cast iron, pilot light and a gas valve. I suspect that it's combis that are the most unreliable as they are the most complex. A condensing system boiler sits between the cast iron lump and combis.

Particularly after 1800 on a Friday night in the middle of winter and weather to match the winters of 2009/10 or 10/11...

I've just fed that back to the guy who surveyed a house for us. He still recommends combis. Reading between the lines I think he's seen a fair few houses wrecked by frozen pipes & tanks.

Andy

Nah. His mate gets a trade deal on combis.

If there is more than one person on a house, dont get a combi.

Or make the combi heat a cylinder - maybe using the direct heating capability for kitchen only. (Yes, that might imply a tank...)

At which point the pint of a combi - that its cheap - no longer has any relevance.

Combis are cheap because there is no header tank hot water cylinder electricalshower pumps or heat bank. The moment you add these back in,. it ceases to be cheap.

Or if you decide a massively powerful combi will in fact meet the needs of two people using hot water, then its also no longer cheap.

Depends on how you look at it... combis are very similar to system boilers, and are almost always based on the same platforms. However the volume of sales quite often drives the prices of them lower than for the equivalent system boiler in spite of having the extra PHE and diversion valve.

(e.g. quick check at bhl.co.uk, they have a Vaillant ecotec 24kW combi for £967, and the system boiler for £1011 even though that is petty much a subset of the former (different firmware probably though))

There are also some situations where having the additional DHW capability direct from the combi can be useful - typically when say the kitchen is where the boiler is, but there is a long dead leg to the cylinder. So using the combis DHW for just a kitchen tap can makes sense. As could for example using it to drive a mains pressure shower when the rest of the DHW is from a gravity fed cylinder. Chances are even if the combi costs more, the difference is less than the cost of a decent shower pump.

Not much in it really. In my last place I needed to go the combi route since I was losing the loft space that contained the cylinder etc. IIRC the 35kW combi[1] was similar money to the 24kW Vaillant system boiler that I fitted here last year.

[1] Ideal ISAR - selected because it fitted the gap in the kitchen. They were so new then that no one knew what a dismal reputation for PCB failures they were about to acquire! In reality the cold water main in that place could only muster about 17 lpm, and in the summer months the combi could just about keep pace with it at full tilt. It coped well enough with 5 people and two bathrooms, could do one really decent shower or two "ok" ones at the same time. Bath filling was slightly slower but not much (which was more of a reflection of how badly the previous stored water system worked).

John makes most of the points I would have made.

You do have the option of a heatbank, as you say, so not necessarily needing the tank & cylinder. (Yes, heatbank is close to equivalent to a cylinder.) In some configurations of property having that near the bathroom, and using directly heated water elsewhere will help with design and slow delivery over long pipes.

Last time I looked, some time ago, I too found system boiler prices higher than combis.

If potable hot water is regarded as an advantage, you also get that.

Heating installers and repairers also get their good natures seriously abused by members of the public, calling them out for a 'free quote', when they have no intention of giving anyone the work but are just intent on picking their brains.

Some installers will, if they suspect that is what is happening, give misleading advice.

You also get regular calls where a repairer diagnoses a fault and has to order a replacement part. The client will then ring back (or not) and say they've got someone cheaper or they've decided to do it themselves. Or just don't return calls, when the part has been obtained, to make an appointment for it to be installed. Most heating installers charge for the diagnosis.

I'd imagine they get seriously pissed off after some years.

Someone should do a TV series, like Rogue Traders, but about rogue customers. They are far more numerous.

Indeed! how *dare* customers ask questions to sift out the crabby, illiterate, d******ds who will "overprice, bodge & run" in the all too typical traditional nature of this lowly "profession"....

Further tarring themselves & their "trade" with more s**te...

must be something to do with "being in business"...maybe they've checked up on reputations in the meantime...

if they think they can get away with it...

but the better ones who don't piss about will probably have a loyal following of repeat business, rather than a constant serial stream of dissatisfied "one offs"... with attendant moaning about their being "hard done by"...

don't get done get Dom!

Jim K

Oh dear, you are a very angry man about heating installers. Never mind, have a nice cup of tea and a sit down in a dark rooom.

Really? How so? If they suspect they won't get any work from it and their time is being deliberately wasted, there's nothing wrong with it. Caveat emptor.

You have been defended the rights of the clueless, incompetent and Walter Mitty types to dispense misleading advice on the Today's DIY' thread. How is this different?

Really? You've experienced this, have you? Like you diagnose the fault, give an estimate for a new part and they ring up to say they can get that part cheaper from another company or they're going to buy the part, now they know what's wrong, and do it themselves.

What's wrong with that? If you called a taxi and had it standing outside your door for 15 minutes, they'd have the meter running and charge for their time, even if you decided you didn't need the taxi.

So why shouldn't a heating contractor charge for his time in fault finding, even if you decide not to use him to repair it.

Yes, they get some business that way, and they advertise and they get people trying to get something for nothing from them, as people often do.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required