If you can't reset the print server to factory default then you could have a long job here if you haven't used the print servers recently.
Bit of background; the way two peices of kit on an IP network communicate at low level is using the MAC address, when you access something using it's IP address PC's, switches and routers have to get the MAC address for that device by what is termed ARPing for it. The PC and routers then store this information for each device they have communicated with recently in what is known as an ARP table. Typing ARP -a displays the contents of this table.
So what you have to do is to get the entries for these devices into the ARP table and the only way I can see of doing this is to ping every device on the sub net and then go looking in the ARP table for the MAC addresses you already know.
There is a ping sweep application that does one better and provides the IP versus MAC for you available free at
formatting link
will make pinging a large network easier, I just tried it and it works.
When you have loaded it (and the WinPcap library it tells you about) you just type:
nmap.exe -sP 172.101.100.* return
but replace the 172.101.100.* with your network address range and you will be rewarded with a screen full of IP / MAC addresses.
Load the output into a text editor and search for the MAC address you want.