I had a very nice lawn up until this year when I got lazy in the fall and
instead of raking up all the leaves I did a combination of raking and
running them over with a mulching mower.
Major mistake, as now I have half dead grass, lots of bald spots and
I have aggressively raked up all the thatch and things are looking better,
but I see signs of ant hills, moss, weeds and bare patches.
The grass looks off color green instead of bright green
So how do I repair this situation?
I am located on Eastern Long Island NY so the soil is sandy and like I
said I had a pretty decent looking lawn up until this point.
BTW this is a fairly decent sized property so installing a new lawn is not
the option I want to take.
Up until this point I was using Lebanon 5 step process every year (the
lawn is only 5 years old, new construction house) but I was never really
happy with it and was thinking of going to Scotts this year. I did use it
in October though, step 5 I think.
I appreciate any and all advice on how to make things better!
It sounds like you are doing it the hard and expensive way.
I live in Ohio, not that much different and I always mulch the leaves, I
fertilize only twice a year and seldom need any other chemical help. I have
de-thatched twice in 12 years. I have a great lawn.
The trick is to make the grass happy and weeds unhappy. It is not
making the chemical companies happy. :-)
Check with your local county extension office. Ask them about soil test
to determine where you want to go. Ask them about lawn mowing and
especially how long is should be cut.
Follow their advice and I predict that you will have a better lawn next
year than you have ever had, less work and less money.
Get on a good program of watering properly and cutting proper length.
Sounds like you probably know that part. Scotts is an expensive luxury,
IMO. Routine weed killer is not needed. By neglecting it for a while,
you will have some resurgence of weeds - they will have dropped seed, so
expect them to keep coming for 2-3 years. Spot treat broadleaf weeds
unless they get very heavy. Pull isolated ones, if you have the time.
Each one you take out might mean several thousand fewer seeds :o) With
a large lawn, it is wise to consider changing some area to natural
plants, or islands of shrubs, trees, groundcover, etc, that don't
require much care. Ants belong there. Moss, if it bothers you, is
probably coming up where it is too shady for grass. Moss gardens can be
great! Slow release fertilizer so's it doesn't wash out right away.
You might have alkaline soil - pH test a good idea, with iron or sulfur
depending on pH needs. Sometimes iron or sulfur will green up the grass
when fert not needed.
Question: when you say you raked up all the thatch do you mean with a
standard leaf rake or a thatching rake? The reason I ask is because I
use a mulching mower all season too and I always had a problem with
large brown patches in the spring.
Last fall I invested in a thatching rake, which looks like more like a
medieval weapon than a garden tool, and after doing the final mowing I
raked the entire lawn. I don't have a large back yard (about 800sf)
and it was back-breaking work but I pulled up two contractor's bags
full of debris missed by the mower. Then I overseeded and spread a
This spring, the lawn looks fantastic. My neighbor, who just
overseeded and fertilized, has half a dead lawn.
I'm definitely no horticultural genius. In fact, I hate lawn
maintenance and am one disappointment away from ripping it all out and
laying pavers. But when I looked at my neighbor's lawn I couldn't see
any soil between the grass, just ground-up leaves, moss and dead grass
shoots. I figure that doesn't give seed anything to root into.
A couple of weeks ago she raked the lawn with a standard leaf rake in
preparation for re/overseeding. She got a small pile of debris. Then
I convinced her to use the thatching rake and she pulled up the same
two contractors' bags of crappola. After seeding, her lawn's
One other trick for bare spots: loosen up the soil with a garden claw
or thatching rake, spread the seed, cover it with a thin layer of
bagged topsoil then use a starter fertilizer. Keep it damp for at
least ten days. A faucet timer is great for this. Set it to water
just before dawn so you don't get mold. Elevate the hose on wire
wickets so it doesn't kill the grass underneath.
I'm in Western NY. Most folks here bag the leaves for the trash guys. My Dad
used to mow the leaves with the side discharge mower, and let them rot. Mom
would friek about what the neighbors would think. Dad's lawn hasn't ever
Mine hasn't either, I just mow the leaves and let them rot. Bagging leaves
and raking out the thatch starves the lawn of the nutrients that went into
the grasss. Maybe why you have to fertilize twice a year. All the minerals
are coming up out of the soil, none are rotting and returning.
On Sun, 17 Apr 2005 13:30:29 GMT, "Stormin Mormon"
===============Sorry to say this but I fertoilize my front lawn...( contracted out
to Natural lawn)...but like you I hop on my lawn tractor every fall
and "mow the leaves" and leave them to rot over the winter..
Just too much leaves to even think about raking up...
He may be like me. I have about 1/2 acre in the front of the house. About
one trip around the lawn and I have to empty the bags on the mower. That is
about 15 dumps to do just the front part of the house.
Too time consuming for me.
On my lawn, which is surrounded by forest on 3 sides, I've always
removed most leaves by blowing/raking, but I'd say I probably mulch up
about 20% or so with a mower while continuing to cut it through
November. I live in NJ and never had a problem because of it and my
lawn looks great. This practice will not lead to thatch, which is
something many people seem to worry about, but few lawns actually
suffer from. The finely ground up leaf material quickly decomposes and
is beneficial to the soil. The only way this would create a problem is
if there is so much of it that it actually covers the grass and acts
like a mulch. If you're doing that, then you're mulching too much and
need to remove some by other means.
I agree with the advice to have the soil tested, particularly for PH
and adjust as needed. For routine maintenance, spot weed control is
all that should be required. It's more effective and less harmful for
the environment. Use a pre-emergent crab grass control/fertilizer in
the spring. Spot treat weeds and deal with any insect problems if
necessary in the summer. Don't apply fertilizer during the summer,
wait till late summer/early fall. Do one app then, another late Oct
and you're lawn should do fine.
Not that anyone cares, but,
If I can get the mower on top of it, I mulch it. Limbs, branchs,
dead animals....everything. In the fall I mow the leaves and
pine straw. If the pine straw still is too much, I mow it again.
Quicker and easier then rakeing and bagging. The leaves have
very little detritus left after a mow or two. I have never had a
thatch problem. I have several trees in my yard and I have never
used a dethatcher.
My neighbor uses one of those hole punching dethatchers and has
built in sprinkler system and her yard is not that much nicer
I think the thatch problem is over rated.
On 19 Apr 2005 05:00:05 -0700, firstname.lastname@example.org wrote:
Thatch is caused by fast release fertilisers or over fertilising making
grass roots stay near the surface. Leaves do not cause thatch and are
beneficial for a natural fertiliser and in studies reduce fungal
problems. The only time I had thatch was with Chemlawn liqued type
fertilisers. Mulching 6 inches of leaves every fall till pieces are
small has hurt nothing and reduced my fertiliser need to nearly nothing.
I agree that most commercial fertilizers contribute greatly to thatch
problems and are bad in other ways as well. That may not be the only cause
of thatch, but in the US I would say it is be far the most common. On top of
that it is bad for the overall health of the grass.
I would not put much faith in Jerry Baker. He has some rather hair
brain ideas, although some are OK. Most are OK in theory, until you do all
I remember one of his ideas of spraying something on the lawn as a
fertilizer. Well, it would work but you would need to use about 1,000 times
more than he suggested to come up to any kind of reasonable level and would
pay many times over the cost of conventional fertilizer.
.... This practice will not lead to thatch, which is
Very true and something few people seem to know. The thatch industry
seems to have created a non-monster.
Most everyone around me is concerned with crab grass. After many years
of no control, I have no more or less than anyone else has. The crabgrass
control industry is another one that has created a much bigger problem than
real. I would guess far more than half of all crabgrass control uses is not
needed. My cats tell me they are doing their job of keeping the elephants
out of my home, and I guess they are right, I have not yet seen a one. :-)
I have to agree with that. I will add that most people cut their grass
too short, especially in the hot dry summer. Even if you water, don't cut
the stuff short. Most grasses do better growing 3-4 inches long and they
handle heat, water and weeds much better under those conditions.
All of my comments here apply to areas with similar grass soils and
weather as mine. Since these factors are far different in different areas,
universal statement are seldom really universal.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.