Craftsman Garage Door Remote Problem

Hi all,
Just wanted to pass along a recent experience with my late 80's-vintage Sears Craftsman garage door opener with the Security+ feature of rolling codes for the remotes. Similar problems have been posted here before but I didn't see a clear solution that someone had tried and it worked for them. Here's my story:
I've got two remotes for the opener and both worked fine for years. A couple of months ago one of the remotes stopped working. First thing I did was replace the battery. Didn't fix it.
Next, I dug out the manual to refresh myself on how to program the remotes for the unit. I put the opener into learn mode and tried to program the previously dead remote: no luck. Next, I tried dumping (resetting) all codes in the opener by pressing and holding the learn button for several seconds. What I discovered after that was that I could get either remote to program successfully, but only one at a time. If I reset all codes and programmed the "good" remote first, it would work fine but I could not get the opener to recognize the second remote. Likewise, if I reset the opener and then programmed the "bad" remote first, it would work fine but I could not get the opener to now recognize the second "good" remote! I tried this several times with slight variations thinking that I must be doing something wrong. No luck.
Cutting to the chase: I bought a replacement Liftmaster Security+ remote from the web and it works like a champ. I'm back to having two good remotes-- one old, one new. Something must've happened to the code sequence generator in that one old remote. Problem solved and I didn't have to spend $200 and a Saturday replacing the entire garage door opener. :)
Add pictures here
<% if( /^image/.test(type) ){ %>
<% } %>
Add image file
Upload is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.