My chimney is starting to show some wear and tear so I am trying to
get estimates for repair. Every company I have contacted wants
$95-$150 to do an inspection before they will do the estimate. I had
one guy come over and do the inspection, but of course the other
companies won't take his results and want to do their own. This means
that if I get the customary three estimates before making a decision,
I will be paying over $300 just to find out which company to deal
with. On the upside, they will all take the cost of the inspection
off the final bill if given the repair job.
Is this how most chimney repair companies do business? I am located in
NJ if that makes any difference.
Tell them that you won't do business with companies that charge for estimates.
Sometimes they'll back down, sometimes they won't. Did the one guy that
inspected it give you an estimate for repair? If so, hire him; if not, ask him
to recommend someone.
What was the first bid for. Business must be real good there so
contractors have enough work that they dont want to waste time giving
bids or the oposite, it is your location.
Keep calling no it is not normal. But tuckpointing is the easiest way
for a customer to get a hack that will do a poor job, mainly in not
removing all the deteriorated mortar, and reseting loose brick. Chimneys
deteriorate first on a brick-stone house, neglected they eventualy can
need replacing-rebuilding You need someone good. Several times ive
hired out chimney work and got a crook, and I made them redo it, but I
know what has to be done.
Anytime you want diagnostics done, you will find yourself paying for a
quote. Some call it a service fee. If you take your vehicle in to find out
what a problem is, you will pay a diagnostics fee. If you call a plumber to
find out what a problem is, you will pay a diagnostics fee. Call a HVAC
company out, it won't be a free diagnostics. Same with an electrical
problem, you will pay a service fee.
Most companies will take the diagnostics off the repair bill, should you
decide to go with their company.
This practice is pretty much done in my area. What brought the changes
about was, people in general. There would be some honest person trying to
make a living, paying their help to diagnose a problem (or paying
themselves), put time into a written quote, and hand this over for free.
The not so honest homeowner or business owner would take their quote and
shop it out. Problems arise when someone's diagnostics are not quite right
and someone else does what was quoted. Also, many of people have gone out
of business by doing free work. It just can't be done for everyone that
asks. Many do free work, but it's always for those that fell on hard times.
Of the three chimney sweeps I had come in to give an estimate, two did
not ask for any fees. The very first guy who came in didn't say
anything about an estimate fee, but then faxed a letter saying it was
$50 for the estimate, which I refused to pay as it was not stated upfront.
Look in the yellow pages for a mason who advertises that he specializes in
repairs and verify that he does chimneys. Chimneys are very specialized if
you want quality. A mason I used and who does all the repair work for major
contractors in my area has in all his years of work only done one chimney
and that was as a training exercise with someone who had done them for
years. Even though he is an expert mason, he says he would never do a
chimney himself. It will be hard to find the right guy for your job. Most
masons are hacks.
The housing market is so strong in NJ that contractors have plenty of
It can be hard to even get a decent one to do a job, let alone give
Personally, it doesn't seem too unreasonable to charge for figuring out
wrong with a chimney and giving an estimate. After all, it takes more
time to figure that out than giving an estimate on something like
painting a couple
Even if you have to pay $300 to get 3 estimates, if you choose one
will usually credit back their $100. So, for $200, you not only get 3
also additional advice as to what should be fixed and how.
On Tue, 07 Dec 2004 02:06:30 GMT, email@example.com (Sara) wrote:
Thanks for all of your replies! You guys are so helpful; this NG is a
Update - I found one company who would come out and do a free
estimate. When the guy got here, he took about 10 seconds to give me
a low ball price. All my instincts were going off about this person,
telling me he was not good to deal with.
Another update - one of the companies I'd contacted called me back
today and the price for the inspection had somehow dropped from $95 to
$45. So apparently there is some wiggle room.
I am cautious because unfortunately there have been some "chimney
repair scams" reported in our local paper recently. Although usually
in these scams, the scammer contacts the homeowner first - typically
he is driving by, "notices" a brick lying in the yard, knocks on the
homeowner's door holding the brick, claims it's from the chimney and
says that he's a mason who just happens to have some free time.
The first guy I called, whose inspection fee was pretty high, has been
in business a long time, specializes in chimneys and has done chimney
restoration work at a local college, so maybe he is the guy to deal
with after all.
Take care & thanks again,
You realy should ,if you can aford it, is hire someone to oversee the
work in progress. It is very likely you will be taken. Contractors try
to rip me off all the time, but I know what to look for before I pay. I
always warn them that I will be checking it out, it does not matter.
This happens to me 90% of the time.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.