I only do this for myself at home, but for gas pipe tapered threads, I have used only Pro-dope for years and years, with no evidence of any leaking. Used it on 1/2", 3/4" and 1" pipe. Applied to male threads only, per code. And made connections as tight as I could. And believe me, I take the dangers of natural gas very seriously, so I've checked and re-checked for leaks for weeks after installation.
Recently discovered a tiny leak in the threads on a utility side gas supply pipe fitting that even the gas company didn't detect. It generated a small "bag" of tiny bubbles after a soapy-water spray. Took a couple of DAYS to notice it - could not even smell gas, the leak was so small, but the utility did of course fix it. I am not sure what sealant was used on it - the fitting hadn't been touched for over 10 years, and might have been leaking for that long - but it was not Pro-dope, and it was certainly not teflon; that I could tell.