Just used some decorators caulk after not using it for years. Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't it used to be in a form that was powdery that you could sand lightly?
This acrylic stuff is like bleedin bath sealant... Am I missing something here?
Depends what you're filling... acrylic is not much good for small imperfections in walls, etc. because it results in a very flat (shiny) surface, which tends to show through paint. You can't really sand it, 'cos the sanded finish is poor. It is good for cracks around architraves, in the corners of walls and ceilings, that sort of thing, where you can gun it in and tool it with a spatula or wet finger or whatever. For craters and small imperfections in walls, stuff like Wickes filler (powder that you mix with water) is quite good, and cheap, but sometimes there seems a little "grit", very, very fine sand in it, which can be a B- when feathering out thin. Still, it rubs down easily enough. More expensive fillers (like "Polyfiller") are really, really fine powders. I find the cheaper stuff is OK. Personally, I don't like "ready mixed", 'cos it has a shelf life, bits can get into it, it's mixed to a consistency and you have to fiddle with it anyway to change the consistency, and it's more expensive than the powder.
You can get mix-it-yourself filler to feather really, really well if you add a drop or two of PVA to the mix (*after* adding some water). This can make the stuff unfortunately rather abrasion resistant, though.
As I use it, caulk comes in tubes for a skeleton gun and is for things like gaps between skirtings and unevenesses in walls, down the edges of fitted units, that sort of thing. Stays slightly flexible and is very very sticky so it doesn't come adrift and expose a gap just where you were hoping to hide one.
Filler is for filling dents and things, perhaps sloppily made joints which aren't expected to move slightly, that sort of thing.
Filler you trowel on and sand down. Caulk you get right while it's wet, using a wet finger if needed.
Filler is (often) plaster based, caulk is PVA based.
Sandable caulk used to be available (Radiospares listed it about 10 years ago), but I've not seen it around for a looooong time. I would use it every time if I could get it easily.
HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.