I'm looking to purchase a cabinet saw. I have 220 in my shop currently and
plan on buying 220 machines when ever possible. While doing my research,
I've heard people mention single phase and three phase power but without the
benefits or limitations of each. Can anyone help me understand this a little
bit more or point me in a direction? -mike
I can think of two benefits of 3-phase -
More HP in a smaller frame motor.
Reduced electrical cost both in demand and KW.
Keep in mind that having 220 in your shop doesn't mean you have 3-phase
Yes, real easy. 220 (actually 240v) is single phase. It would be real
strange for a residence to have three phase.
So, you have single phase.
Your question should be whether to use 240v or 120v.
If you have 240v in your shop, then you should use it. It simply works
better; do a search and see what people say about it.
If you don't have 240v, then 120v should be okay also.
guess I didn't make myself clear, Doug. I live in San Jose, but had a
business in Santa Clara. The VOLTAGE is 208 in Santa Clara, as opposed
to 220 (or thereabouts) in San Jose. NOW do you understand what I was
getting at? I thought you'd understand my business was in an industrial
area since I had 3 phase power!!!
Doug Miller wrote:
Santa Clara doesn't have _a_ voltage. Power is brought into Santa Clara
via high-tension transmission lines where the voltage is somewhere around
115,000 volts (115kv). It hits a substation where it is transformed to
lower voltages for distribution (22kv is common in south san jose, for
instance, although newer systems use higher voltages). The 22kv is
then distributed to home, commercial and industrial users. The 22kv will
be transformed to 240v (nominal) single-phase for home users, and typically
480v three phase for commercial (office parks et. al.) and higher voltages for
users. Commercial and industrial users have on-site transformers to produce
various voltages for various purposes - 240/277/208 volt systems are quite
common in commerical and industrial facilities - 277v is very efficient for
flourescent lights while 240/208 is used for industrial purposes. 240 can be
centertapped to ground to provide the common 120 (as is done by the grounded
conductor at your home service entrance, for example). In all cases, the
22kv distribution will be three phase and where the commercial or industrial
entity has its own transformer, the three phase will be distributed to the
business. To save wiring costs, three phase isn't distributed typically
within residential neighborhoods (past the 22kv stepdown transformer).
An office I used to work in had 2 phases of 3 phase supplied to them, so
they had 208v.
It still isn't 3 phase, since they did not get the 3rd phase.
A factory I worked at had real 3 phase, so they used mainly 208v motors,
though some of the big ones were true 3 phase.
On Fri, 24 Oct 2003 15:58:47 GMT, spam email@example.com (Doug Miller)
I thought some of you guys had (domestic) heating that ran off it ?
Here in the UK it depends how your power is delivered. If it's
underground (nearly everyone) then it's a serious spend to get 3
phase. If it's an overhead feed (just the rustics) then it's a lot
cheaper as there's normally line-of-sight to a suitable transformer.
Die Gotterspammerung - Junkmail of the Gods
We use single phase 120/240 with the 240 feeding large loads. It is derived
from a single phase center tapped transformer. In fact you don't see 3 phase
transformers until you get to very large industrial pad mounted units.
The norm here (US) is a smaller single phase transformer hanging on the pole
and serving 2-3 homes. If the 3 phases are available on the pole, usually only
if you live on a main power route, it is possible to add one more transformer
and provide "open vee" 3p delta with a centertap. That uses the existing
service and adds the extra transformer to get the 3d phase. That arrangement
isn't perfect 3 phase and can get some strange phase shifts with unbalanced
loads between phase ab and bc but it does work, particularly if you are just
feeding motor loads that balance out fairly well.
For a bit more money they will add the 3d transformer and give you true 240v
delta or, more common 208v wye with 3 120v to ground legs.
On 25 Oct 2003 01:47:48 GMT, firstname.lastname@example.orgGreg (Gfretwell) wrote:
American electrics terrify me (a lot of your working practices are
seen as screaming nightmares in our standards documents). And you do
it in timber framed buildings too !
But I really don't understand how you can operate a system with such a
mixture of 240 / 208 and 110 / 120 V systems. It must keep the
motor-swap shops in business.
Here in Europe we just have single phase and three phase. Then barring
the half-a-dozen different socket outlet styles, I can move any
appliance around between _any_ two European countries and have it
work, straight off. Standard voltage, right across the continent.
Even dodgy old places like Spain and Greece are now getting their acts
together (15 years ago I installed VFDs in a Spanish factory where we
barely had a working phoneline)
Die Gotterspammerung - Junkmail of the Gods
It is not a hard concept. You only make a mistake once! <g>
Really, the 110 plug will not fit in the 220, and also the other way around.
If you don't understand it, don't play with it. A few do get it wrong, but
It is nice to run 220 a greater distance, with lighter wires, and less
voltage loss. You can't claim that as a disadvantage for us.
It is what happens when you invent something and never abandon any idea each
inventor came up with.
You folks were helped a lot by a war that destroyed enough of your
infrastructure that you had to build it all back at one time, with uniform
standards. We still have major utilities that date back to Thomas Edison.
I have always said, the best thing we could have done was bomb all of our
infrastructure to the ground in 1945 and build new stuff so we would be on
equal footing with the rest of the world. In the long run we would have saved
Most commercial grade motors can be tapped for any of those voltages by
swapping a couple wires in the bell.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.