I am looking to stain/protect my decking but after looking at the prices of
the stain it seems that each small tin which I need 5 of is going to cost me
about £120. Is there a cheaper way of doing this? It has been treated at the
timber yard but I wanted to go for a dark brown stain.
Efficacy and appearance of wood treatments is directly proportional to price.
At the high end you have products like Jotun which can be obtained in
any colour you like, look superb and will last for many years,
protecting the wood well. This originates from Norway and is widely
used for property preservation. I've used their Trebbit product and it
has lasted perfectly for over 8 years. I expect to re-do it the year
In the upper mid range, there is Sikkens and Sadolin. Each has a
number of ranges, with the better ones (e.g. Sadolin Classic) coming in
a reasonable range of colours and are solvent based. I've used this one
and reckon the life is about 7 years in most cases. They have lower
end garden building products as well, but these do not seem to be a lot
better than other brands.
In the lower mid range, there is Cuprinol. Many of their products
have now been switched to water based, although at least these come in
a few reasonably acceptable colours. There are still some solvent
based preservatives from them, although the colour range is limited.
I've also used these on garden buildings and reckon on about 5 years
At the low end, there is the own-brand stuff from the DIY stores.
These are almost always water based and come in very poor shades of
colour with the result that the finished result will make the house
look like the one in Play School. Penetration is not at all good and
lifetime limited. Two years is typical, three if lucky, but it is
showing bare wood in that time.
So I would choose based on the wanted lifetime of the item, and
consequently don't use the low end stuff any longer. Apart from the
direct cost because of repeat treatments, there is the time taken.
For a deck, which presumably you would want to have for a minimum of
ten years, I wouldn't use anything less than a Sikkens or Sadolin
product - it's a false economy.
However, you should be able to do better on pricing if you shop around,
especially on line. Unless it's a vast deck, perhaps half of the
figure you mention?
I think you also have to weight it against the cost of replacing the
deck if it deteriorates. Again, economising on wood preservatives
really is a false economy.
The cheap stuff my have less of the preservative in it who can say
without the expense of an analysis. What is difficult to gauge is the
quality of the stain. The colouring is an earth based dye so the
penetration is not going to be deep whatever.
If the wood is white pine then even if the grain of the colouring is
small, little or no penetration can take place. Even solvents are
unlikely to go deep without pressure treatment to rip open the cells of
In the good old days the stuff developed out of the gas the Germans
developed to kill Jews was widely used. However along with agent orange
and some weedkillers, lindane is no longer in use.
Virtually all preservatives since then have been very expensve metal
salts or some pretty weak stuff. I would check out the contents of the
stuff you are buying and compare that with the alternatives before
settling on a colourant.
I am looking at the Jotun Trebitt but I am trying to work out the coverage.
Says here http://www.woodcaredirect.co.uk/product_detail.cfm?ID "19
Typical coverage per litre 8 - 10m2 (is that per coat? will it need 3
Sorry, I should have been bit clearer. When mentioning Jotun, I was
really talking about the manufacturer. I used Trebitt for a garden
building application where I wanted a particular final appearance.
There is a translucent stain version as well.
The best information can be found on their Norwegian web site where
there are also colour cards.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.