Maybe it's the cold & dark, short days talking ... ;o)
Best do it last then! The insulation at the moment is terrible! You know if you had a 20 year old pillow (not feathers) that had fallen to pieces inside and gone all lumpy? Dump 200 pillow fulls of that crap in my attic and add years of dust and you get the idea!! Probably only about 5cm deep in most places too.
reason, full of windblown crap, and the cold wind blowing through. I had to clear the loft to have my worms killed some years ago, and hoovered a whole bin bag of soot and dust out. I stapled the stuff up to the roof joists, and then used some strips of hardboard to spread the fixing and stop it tearing. Stapled these over the top, along the joists.
I left largish gaps top & bottom to prevent condensation build up.
If a wide plumber had been called out to fix my CH header tank he'd have been out of luck before I put a new hatch in - the original one was only 18" square.
In houses of this age and construction the original under-tile sealing was often done with lime mortar applied in a fillet between each row of tiles,a technique known as torching. It's effective while intact but tends to drop off after a few decades due to movement in the roof - you could have a go at it if you fancy continuing an ancient tradition :-)
Probably the biggest thing you cuold do would be to hoover the place up. Probably need a cyclone vac, not sure, but bag types tend to clog very quickly on building dust.
If you still find you need to do something with the slate roof I wouldnt put waterproof stuff under the joists, asking for trouble. Something more porous maybe, that allows airflow..
Just to get things straight we're not strictly talking about 'pilot' holes here are we?
The way I would (probably) do it would be to drill a clearance hole in the chipboard (not a pilot hole) and no hole in the underlying joist. The screw will then be able to pull the chipboard tight down onto the joist.
If I was being lazy I wouldn't bother with the clearance hole in the chipboard. As we're not really wanting to pull the chipboard hard down onto the joists, the screws are only to stop it sliding around, it will work OK. You just need to check that the chipboard is snug against the joist before driving the screw in.
A pilot hole would be in the joist and (almost certainly) in addition to a clearance hole in the chipboard. The pilot hole is to locate the screw in the joist and to prevent it splitting the wood. Modern screws like Turbogold really don't need the hole to prevent them splitting the wood.
And the real trick is; once you have all the crap in a bin-bag, don't catch it and tear it on the hatch trap as you try to manouver yourself and it out! :-( Very P'd off I was too!
That's the way I did it (and countersunk the holes) for the first half of the loft before I had the turbogolds.
That's what I did it with the turbogolds for the rest of the job, and wished I'd discovered them sooner. Since I was usually kneeling on the board being screwed down there was no problem about it being in contact with the joist. Even if the pieces aren't in close contact they usually seem to pull together OK, it seems that the screws grip better in real wood than in chipboard so will just strip away any thread in the chipboard if required to pull it down.
Theres nothing wrong with the timber getting wet on a regular basis up there, so long as it dries off promptly. Timber can happily last centuries like that. And unlined slate roofs allow exactly that to happen. I think this point is often not appreciated.
You need to continue to allow the wind/drying process to happen. I'm still not convinced theres a problem to solve. Any room in any house that hasnt been hoovered in 70 years is going to be filthy... So as I said before, I'd just hoover the place.
HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.