I have a ranch house that has a small decorative gable (I think that's
what it's called). It's like a short (maybe 2 feet tall) and wide
(maybe 7 feet across) section of roof that juts out, kind of like a
dormer with no windows. This feature ends about 2-3 inches from the
roof line (think of a dormer where the window would be about three
inches form the edge of the roof). the shingles in this narrow strip
of roof need to be replaced, they're all cracked, curling. The rest
of the roof is fine (second layer is about 6-7 years old, we bought
the house with two layers a few years ago). There's no water coming
in (that I can see in attic or in the house), but I want to try to
address this myself. How would I arrange the shingles in a 3 inch
wide by 7 foot long strip of roof? It's narrower than even the tabs
of a shingle. Just get several rectangular pieces and lay them in a
row each overlaopping the previous one?? I'll work on posting a
picture if you think it'll help.
A picture would be nice, but it sounds to me like you've got a gable.
I hate it when they leave the tiny little piece of roof for purely
decorative purposes. It's a pain to maintain roof that doesn't actually
Here are some options:
* Ask three roofers to look at it. If that section is failing, likely
the rest of the roof is about to go. If you catch it early, you *might*
be able to use the manufacturer's warranty. If nothing else, you'll be
prepared for the worst. You don't have to actually hire the roofers if
you don't want to.
* To fix it yourself, remove all the shingles and underlayment down to
bare wood. Replace any damaged wood. Apply new underlayment. Apply a
layer of shingles with the tabs hanging off the edge of the roof
(assuming three-tab shingles). Cut off the overhang. Apply roofing tar
to the nails if you want. Cut tabs off shingles so they'll fit, then
nail them on top of the solid layer. *Do* apply roofing tar to these
nails. Install and seal flashing, and you're done.
I just took a picture of the area.... so you see these shingles are
done... It appears (from my perspective that when the second layer
was put on, this area never got it, as the rest of the roof edges look
to have more layers than this section). No other areas of the roof
look at all like this......
Why would this one area look so beaten, while the rest of the roof
appears fine? I'd send a shot of the rest of the roof, but its all
snow. The rest of the shingles are in the same shape as the ones you
see going up the gable (though I'm sure there's no where near enough
showing to get an idea.)
Look at the shingle at the right edge of the photo. I think this was
the original installation method:
* Decking material (but I can't really see it)
* Covered with underlayment, such as roofing felt
* Covered with a base layer of solid shingle material (no slots to
make the tabs)
* With flashing on top of the base layer
* Covered with a finish layer of trimmed shingle tabs for appearance
It looks like everything was fastened together with roofing tar. Tar
gets brittle in the cold and can lose its hold. It gets sticky again in
hot weather. That's probably why this area failed and nothing else did.
I find it strange that the top layer of shingles looks like it was on
_top_ of the flashing. That is a no-no, because it allows water to run
between the shingle layers. On a tiny span like this, it probably won't
leak, but it _will_ contribute to the failure of the tar.
Beyond that nearest shingle, it looks like both layers of shingles are
missing and the underlayment is failing.
Fixing this won't be hard, just time-consuming, frustrating, and messy.
I think my previous description of repair still applies. Use some
roofing nails to fasten mechanically, and put both layers of shingle
under the flashing.
Of course, I'm in Texas and you're up in the Northeast somewhere,
guessing by the architecture. You'll have to check locally to see if
there are different requirements in your area.
I'd just replace/cover the whole area with white flashing, and be done
with it. In a fancy house, they would put a strip of copper there. Usual
cautions about getting the flashing up under the siding, and under the
adjacent shingles on the ends, apply. A strip of that sticky stuff they
use on eves and in valleys is probably a good idea, once you clean out
all the rotted stuff and build back with solid wood. No way would I put
shingles back there- wrong material for the job on a tiny strip like
that. You can buy the flashing in rolls, and blacksmith it yourself, or
any local sheet metal shop could make you up sticks on their bending
Flashing was my first thought since it looks like it's not even visible
from anywhere. Even if it was, nothing wrong with white flashing as long
as it's not hacked like an old can in the road.
Generically called WSU - Waterproof Shingle Underlayment. It's rather
expensive for a regular 36" roofing roll ($80-100+) considering what will
be used. May want to look into Flashing Tape. Kind of the same sticky
back suff but comes in narrow rolls. Often stated as used for chimneys,
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.