Pardon me folks, I didn't know how to post and wound up posting my
question in another thread. Thanks Jerry for the response. I've since
broadened my search for refrigerators. Now, in addition to the GE
freezer-on-top, 24.6 cu. ft "Profile Arcata" refrigerator, I am
considering both Maytag and Amana brands. Reading postings in this
group and others I have found Maytag to have generally the best
reviews. I need as much refrigerator capacity as possible; quiet
operation (well insulated) and lower cost are the two additional most
important items. (The fewer bells-and-whistles, the better) The
Maytag and Amana are freezer-on-bottom refrigerators; not my favorite,
but the capacity is good and the price fairly reasonable. Both of
these are 25 cu. ft. with almost 18 cu. ft. of refrigerator space.
Price ranges from a little over $1000 to $1250.00. Thanks, Dorian
I am looking for a top freezer refrigerator with the maximum capacity
for the refrigerator at the lowest cost. I don't need any of the
bells-and-whistles which seem to come, inevitably, with the larger
sized, better quality refrigerators. The largest refrigerator I would
find with the conventional top freezer style is the GE Profile Arctica
refrigerator with a capacity of 24.6 Cu. Ft.
It is model number: PTS25LHSWW. However, in reading posts to this
group about GE refrigerators I have seen a lot of criticism of the
quality of GE products. Does anyone know anything about this model?
Or are all GE refrigerators of poor quality these days? And if so,
what company, if any, has well made refrigerators? Thank you for your
From: jerry email@example.com - view profile
Date: Tues, Dec 19 2006 3:12 pm
Email: jerry firstname.lastname@example.org
Don't know much about top-freezer models. We just bought a GE Profile
side-by-side to replace a _6 year old_ Amana that died on Thanksgiving
day, compressor. I'm kinda down on Amanas right now. Prior to the
compressor failure, we had lost the auger motor, and we were on the 4th
icemaker unit. Meanwhile the 20-some year old GE in the garage just
keeps chugging along, one of the reasons we decided to go with a GE to
replace the Amana.
I have a Maytag side by side, and would never own another. It
has required service about 6 times in 6 years. The Sears repair guy
says that, of all the brands they service, Maytag is the worst.
FWIW, I owned a Sears Coldspot prior to the Maytag; and it did
not require a single service call in 25 years.
I've always had very good service from Whirlpool and Kenmore refrigerators.
(Kenmore is made by Whirlpool, so that's not much of a surprise.)
Before you spend big bucks on a new bottom-freezer model, see if you can rent
one, or buy a used one for a hundred bucks. Use it for a month. Then see if
you're still interested in getting one. The previous owners of our house left
one of those behind -- my wife and I both hated it. We have a side-by-side
now, and it's great.
Doug Miller (alphageek at milmac dot com)
FYI, there are also Kenmore-branded fridges made by Frigidaire these
In the side by side realm at least, it's easy to avoid them if you
choose the kenmores with water filters accessible from teh front
though--those are made by whirlpool.
As long as we're talking about Sears, I should mention their pricing.
When we bought our GE Profile on Thanksgiving weekend, we looked at
Sears first, then Best Buy. The EXACT same model was priced $400 more
at Sears, the one at Sears was on "sale", $200 off, yeah right.
And if you're interested in extended warranties (we hardly ever buy
them), the warranty at Sears cost nearly twice as much as the one at
Sears offered free delivery via mail-in rebate OR 12 month 0%
financing. Best Buy offered free delivery (no rebate involved) AND 18
month 0% financing. Kinda made our decision a no-brainer.
Yeah, we ran into the same thing when buying a washer and dryer a few years
ago: we found a Whirlpool set at Circuit City that was several hundred dollars
cheaper than the *identical* equipment at Sears that happened to have the
Kenmore brand on it instead of Whirlpool.
Extended warranties are almost always a bad deal regardless of where you buy
Doug Miller (alphageek at milmac dot com)
Thanks for all the suggestions. I'm going to take a look at Kitchen
Aid and Whirlpool and visit Best Buys - I hadn't thought of them. As
for brands, there has been tremendous consolidation in the refrigerator
business in recent years. I can't remember what brands are owned by
who but I was astonished to find how many brands are owned now by
single companies. My impression is that refrigerators have lost in
reliability over the years while gaining in features. I can do without
the latter, personally. Dorian
You really should open the yellow pages and find one or two small locally
owned stores which have their own service department. Many of these stores
are part of a large buying consortium, so their prices are often just as low
as the big chains. And, if you ever need service, they'll actually remember
who you are.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.