What's your experience with powered hotwater heater sacrificial anodes?
>formatting link>
> My State GS6-40-HBR-SG is a 40-gallon short atmospheric LP hotwater tank
> a. GS6 = Gas Commercial/Residential standard atmospheric model series
> b. 40 = 40 gallon
> c. H = short
> d. B = propane
> e. R-SG (FVIR safety system)
> f. Date of manufacture: February 2006
>
> It failed after only 20 years, where there are two main failure modes:
> a. Calcium carbonate precipitation causes heat stress on the bottom
> b. Steel corrosion causes leaks on the sides
>
> Most tanks nowadays, are around 22 inches and around 60 inches tall, or
> taller and natural gas, so a replacement is really difficult to source. >
> As far as I can tell, only two water heaters on earth fit that space.
> a. State model GS6-40-BRBS-401
> b. A.O. Smith model GCRL-40-LP
>
> I need to replace it, where I've removed it but now I need a replacement.
> It's in a crawlspace so I have no options on size, which is limited to
> a. Tank Diameter: 20 inches (maybe 1/2 inch leeway)
> b. Height to top of draft hood: 51 inches (maybe 1/2 inch leeway)
> c. Vent Size: 3-inch atmospheric
>
> I don't care about the brand or warranty, as well water "preserves" tanks
> better'n municipal water (in my case) due to the LSI being nearly balanced. >
> Well, it's nearly balanced at 60 degrees F input but at 125 degrees F
> inside, it certainly precipitates out calcium given my well water has a
> calcium hardness of over 200 ppm and a total alkalinity over 200 ppm (as
> repeatedly determined by Leslie's free pool water analysis over the years). >
> Given the total dissolved solids are about 500 ppm, there is still an
> electro chemical reaction that will corrode the iron in micro cracks in the
> 'pyrex' coating of the inner shell, so my question is one of electrodes. >
> There is zero chance the sacrificial anode is ever going to come out.
> So, I'm wondering, what's your experience with the new powered electrodes? >
> The brand name is two hundred bucks, but they are as cheap as fifty bucks.
> If the fifty buck one works, that might be worth it to save the steel. >
> What's your experience with powered hotwater heater sacrificial anodes?
I change my water heater's sacrificial anode every 2 years (as directed in the manual). My water heater is 28 years old and still going strong.