Re: What's your experience with powered hotwater heater sacrificial anodes?

Nov 17, 2026 Last reply: 52 minutes ago 1 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

Maria Sophia

Thanks for letting us know that your water heater is almost 3 decades old and still working fine without leaking, where that's WONDERFUL to know! That's a testament to your good maintenance, and, oh, maybe a water softener or maybe a sediment filter, or maybe balanced LSI…

Read the full reply


What's your experience with powered hotwater heater sacrificial anodes?


>
formatting link
>
> My State GS6-40-HBR-SG is a 40-gallon short atmospheric LP hotwater tank
> a. GS6 = Gas Commercial/Residential standard atmospheric model series
> b. 40 = 40 gallon
> c. H = short
> d. B = propane
> e. R-SG (FVIR safety system)
> f. Date of manufacture: February 2006
>
> It failed after only 20 years, where there are two main failure modes:
> a. Calcium carbonate precipitation causes heat stress on the bottom
> b. Steel corrosion causes leaks on the sides
>
> Most tanks nowadays, are around 22 inches and around 60 inches tall, or
> taller and natural gas, so a replacement is really difficult to source. >
> As far as I can tell, only two water heaters on earth fit that space.
> a. State model GS6-40-BRBS-401
> b. A.O. Smith model GCRL-40-LP
>
> I need to replace it, where I've removed it but now I need a replacement.
> It's in a crawlspace so I have no options on size, which is limited to
> a. Tank Diameter: 20 inches (maybe 1/2 inch leeway)
> b. Height to top of draft hood: 51 inches (maybe 1/2 inch leeway)
> c. Vent Size: 3-inch atmospheric
>
> I don't care about the brand or warranty, as well water "preserves" tanks
> better'n municipal water (in my case) due to the LSI being nearly balanced. >
> Well, it's nearly balanced at 60 degrees F input but at 125 degrees F
> inside, it certainly precipitates out calcium given my well water has a
> calcium hardness of over 200 ppm and a total alkalinity over 200 ppm (as
> repeatedly determined by Leslie's free pool water analysis over the years). >
> Given the total dissolved solids are about 500 ppm, there is still an
> electro chemical reaction that will corrode the iron in micro cracks in the
> 'pyrex' coating of the inner shell, so my question is one of electrodes. >
> There is zero chance the sacrificial anode is ever going to come out.
> So, I'm wondering, what's your experience with the new powered electrodes? >
> The brand name is two hundred bucks, but they are as cheap as fifty bucks.
> If the fifty buck one works, that might be worth it to save the steel. >
> What's your experience with powered hotwater heater sacrificial anodes?

I change my water heater's sacrificial anode every 2 years (as directed in the manual). My water heater is 28 years old and still going strong.

Thanks for letting us know that your water heater is almost 3 decades old and still working fine without leaking, where that's WONDERFUL to know!

That's a testament to your good maintenance, and, oh, maybe a water softener or maybe a sediment filter, or maybe balanced LSI water?

If you replace the anode, that makes a HUGE difference in life for sure. Here's a photo of my sacrificial anode. No way is that ever coming out.

formatting link

Presumably you also flush the sediment out on schedule also. Do you?

formatting link

My brass valve was clogged so I had to remove it completely to flush.

formatting link

Surprisingly, the "sediment" was "sandy" brown stuff, with no rust.

formatting link
I put it under pool acid and it only fizzed slightly, whatever it is.

But the problem I'd have with replacing the anode is there's no room.

formatting link

The failure modes are many, but the 1st of 2 main modes are sediment collects in the bottom, causing the gas burner to heat up more because the temperature probe is in the water above the insulator, which causes the thermal expansion to be greater and more importantly, the difference in thermal expansion coefficients between the steel and glass enamel causes micro cracks in the glass which exposes the iron in the steel to corrosion, which, if you have high calcium carbonate, "partially" heals but not fully.

The second failure mode is the expansion coefficients of the steel tank and the glass envelope are different so micro cracks form, which is the whole point of the sacrificial anode, but, when it wears out, then the steel is corroded, which is why you replaced your sacrificial anode every two years.

You didn't state what matters for the LSI in your water, but you can guess that your water is reasonably well balanced at the incoming water temperature, although all water has a raised LSI when it's heated up.

formatting link

What matters is the following, all of most people already know by heart. a. pH (assume outgassing for well water) b. Temperature (incoming and heated) c. Calcium d. Alkalinity e. TDS

There are plenty of non-pool-related references on the LSI as it was developed expressly to understand municipal water systems balancing.

formatting link
formatting link
formatting link
formatting link
formatting link
formatting link
etc. Although, if anyone owns a pool, the LSI is 2nd-nature to them already.
formatting link
since the surfaces attacked are the plaster pool & the equipment.

The problem in my situation is inherent in the fact that I have to replace the hotwater heater with a shorty because of the severe lack of headroom.

That's why I am considering adding a powered anode while the water heater is sitting in my driveway with unlimited headroom to remove the old one.

Do the electronics experts here know if these powered anodes really work?

formatting link

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required