I have a 20 year old in-ground pool which actually is in extremely good condition with virtually no cracks. I am in the process of rennovating the entire pool area, and one of the possible changes will be to place flagstone around the pool. Currently it has Cool Deck (sp?) coating over concrete around the pool There are perhaps 3 significant cracks around the pool deck area (perhaps 1/8" cracks) with the Cool Deck having come off those areas a bit (perhaps 1" on either side of the cracks) . One contractor (pool work only) told me that the entire deck must be jack-hammered up before placing the flagstone with an estimated cost of between 16K-25K for construction of the deck. The higher end price would place the project out of my budget, and 16K certainly is more than I would like to spend. The other contractor (landscaper who says that he has done multiple flagstone pool decks) tells me that is absolutely not necessary to jack hammer the deck prior to placing flagstone. He said that you can place the flagstone directly on the Cool Deck, or alternatively scrape off the Cool Deck and then place the Flagstone onto the concrete base. Of course there will be some extra work required regarding the pool coping to make it look appropriate with the higher flagstone level. I have yet to receive a bit from him.
Who is right?