I just bought a Harbor Breeze 52" Avian Ceiling Fan (Model #75849)
from Lowes. Unfortunately, this model comes with a remote control
function and I need to hardwire it. The sales representative convinced
me that all I need to do is to throw away the ceiling fan remote
control and receiver and then hardwire the light to the wall switch
and hardwire the fan connection to a Lutron (SFSQ-F Single Pole Fan
Control Quiet 3-Speed) fan control.
As you are probably aware, there are all types of warnings in the
instructions not to wire this remote control fan to a solid state
speed control. I find this interesting because the receiver for the
remote control unit states that it is a solid state speed control.
Am I correct in assuming that if I remove the wireless receiver and
hook it up to the Lutron solid state speed control switch everything
will work fine? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.
The speed control for your fan is built in as an integral part of the motor
using its own switching power supply. There are electronics in front of the
motor that are used to change the duty cycle for the motor. By using a
light dimmer in front to supply the fan unit, the power supply and control
drive electronics in the fan unit will be damaged!
What you really need is to return the fan unit, and get yourself simple
ceiling fan that is compatible with an external dimmer!
The light dimmers change the duty cycle to the load, not the voltage. This
is how they give the dimming effect. This duty cycle shift moves in phase in
relation to the AC source. The effective drive to the load is reduced,
because of the phase shift between the output of the dimmer in relation to
the input is offset, and thus giving a lower average voltage output based on
the duty cycle offset. The spiking or switching effect of this offset will
damage most electronic devices, except for simple loads such as heating
elements or incandescent light bulbs.
There are some types of compact fluorescent lamps that are designed to be
able to work with a standard light dimmer. They employ some complex
circuitry in the ballast supply to compensate for the duty cycle offset.
Regular compact florescent lamps can be damaged with a standard light
< firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote in message
So the bottom line is that the speed control is not encased within the
receiver itself? The receiver has writing on it that states: 120V/60Hz
MAX. Motor 1A Ceiling Fan Only Max. Light 300 watts incandescent only
solid state speed control 0406.
he's saying that they are in separate boxes, and that he can separate
the motor from the electronics. I can't tell if you know his model
and are saying he is wrong, or if you are speaking generally
I know he's not talking about putting one speed controller in front of
the other speed controller, which seems to be what you think he wants
I have a problem with your using the terms dimmer and dmming effect.
We're talking about the motor speed and dimming refers to lamp
It's funny that I should complain, because Im the only one on this
list it seems who does use dimmers to control fan speed, but I do that
only when it works, and for table and other fans for which the wall
mounted fan speed controls which are available don't work easily.
When I use a lamp dimmer for speed control, the fan is where I can
touch the motor case frequently in the first few hours to make sure
it's not getting hotter and hotter or overheating, and where it is
handy to slow the rotation speed enough to make sure I can't slow it
to a stop, where it would get likely get hotter than it can take.
A ceiling fan would be the hardest of fans to check this way, having
to stop the fan (since the big blades mean one can't come t it from
the back.) and climb on a chair everytime one wants to touch it.
And since they are expensive, much more than the free table fans I
have, and worth the effort to get a real fan speed controller, even if
one mounted it in a box next to the bed.
But I think you are referring to a fan speed controller whereever you
say dimmer, and I wanted to point that out. Hmmm. Reading to the
end, the second choice also seems likely, that you are referring to a
dimmer that contros LIGHTS and if so, we need to be sure your words
would also apply to a fan speed controller and a fan.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.