Hello All,
We've decided to get a Keeprite Two Stage Variable Speed Mid-efficiency gas furnace for our renovated 1500ft² 80 year old story and a half bungalow and have narrowed it down to two installers. Both have included duct cleaning, re-routing of the basement cold air return to the floor, and installation of the two fresh air ducts now required by the City of Edmonton, Alberta, where we live. Both installers are members in good standing with the BBB.
The difference between the two installers are system upgrades, and therefore, price. Installer 1 quoted $3600 complete, including (1) a radius return with 2 fins, and (2) a manually-operated 50% damper that is put in position at Halloween and returned to open when the outside water tap is turned back on. We tried to get the price reduced by not including the damper, but Installer 1 believes that the system should be installed complete to allow for the most comfort in the house. Installer 2 quoted $2900 complete, but without a radius return or damper. When asked if these would be useful upgrades, Installer 2 disagreed.
I've done as much research as I could on radius returns and dampers, including the forums posted by the knowledgeable folks on this site, and understand that there are some benefits with these (radius return -
quieter, and more efficient use of filter; damper - keep too much cool air from recirculating in the winter, especially with a variable speed motor running constantly). In addition, we would like to go with Installer 1, because he knew pretty much more than the other three Installers who quoted combined and was easier to discuss things with. However, we're not certain if the extra $700.00 for the two upgrades is
worth it.
Any commments would be greatly appreciated.
Regards, DL