I have a circuit breaker problem that i hope someone can help me with. In
the last 4 or 5 months when we have run the dishwasher we have noticed a
foul odor that we thought was coming from the dishwasher. A few times the
circuit breaker would kick off so we thought maybe the timer on the
dishwasher was sticking and causing an overheating which was causing the
smell and the breaker to pop. Well the other day my wife noticed the smell
was coming from the breaker box. I checked the breakers and the one that
goes to the dishwasher was loose. I bought another breaker at the hardware
store(20 amp, single pole) and when I took the old one out, the casing was
burned away where it plugs into the circuit panel and breaker smelled of the
odor we had been smelling.
So I replaced it then had to leave a short while later. My wife came home
about 20 minutes later and she smelled the same odor again. The dishwasher
was not running.
I'm starting to think there is a major problem and I can't figure out what.
We haven't added anything to the circuit. As it is now, the kitchen
refrigerator and a few 3 other plugs are on this circuit. I have the
microwave plugged into one plug and the dishwasher is plugged into one. The
refrigerator was the only thing running and it's only 2 or 3 years old. I
doubt there is a problem with it but that remains to be seen. The only
electrical work done in the last eight months has been an electrician
redoing some wiring in my heater closet in my garage and it's a different
circuit. This is not the first problem I have had with breakers either. In
the last 3 years I have replaced 2 other breakers (another 20amp and the
100amp main.) They seem to wear out the same way: the casing where the
breaker plugs in being kind of singed or melted. Is this normal? The home is
24 years old and I've been told that breakers wear out but I thought the
wearing out had to do with the switch tripping and or not resetting. Anyway,
my wife had the breaker off when I came home so I reset it and have been
waiting all evening to set if it starts smelling again. I haven't smelled
I don't want to leave the breaker off because the refrigerator is on it but
I'm worried about going to bed tonight. The smoke alarms all work so...
Any good advice out there about what might be causing this? I don't mind
paying an electrician but I don't want to call one out if it's something
simple. I'm also wondering if there was still a little crud or something on
the contact of the bus bar that might have caused the stink when I plugged
it in because I'm not smelling it and it's been 4 hours or so.
The microwave, refrigerator, and dishwasher should all have pretty much
their own circuits. But that should just be causing your breakers to open,
How does the breaker bus look? Any burn marks on it, or just the breaker?
I read somewhere about the Federal Pacific problem. The panel brand is
"Bryant" as are the breakers. The replacement breakers have been
"Cutler-Hammer." The wiring is aluminum. I'm going to take some or all of
the breakers out tomorrow and look the bus over. I guess I should get the
box replaced and all of the breakers. Thanks for all of your input folks. I
appreciate the expertise. Dicky
Jeez, you should have mentioned that stuff in your original
post - esp the aluminum bit.
: > The microwave, refrigerator, and dishwasher should all have
: > their own circuits. But that should just be causing your
: > open, not burn.
: > How does the breaker bus look? Any burn marks on it, or just
: > Aluminum wiring?
Missed this part of the original post, didja?
"the casing was burned away where it [the breaker] plugs into the circuit
panel ... I have replaced 2 other breakers ... they seem to wear out the same
way: the casing where the breaker plugs in being kind of singed or melted. "
How is cleaning the wire and applying antioxidant to it going to affect in
*any* way the connection between the breaker and the bus bar, where the
I wonder if perhaps the breakers are not the right type for the panel, or if
they were never seated properly when installed.
Doug Miller (alphageek at milmac dot com)
Please tell me this is not a FPE, Federal Pacific Electric panel. If you
have a FPE panel call a electrician and start planning on changing it out to
something works and is still UL listed. FPE lost their UL listing and is out
of business. There is a company that makes replacement breakers, but your
still stuck with the same funky way of connection.
Loose connections anywhere under a load is a recipe for disaster. Circuit
breakers do not "wear out" under normal circumstances, at least in my
experence. Singed or melted bussing is a really bad sign. My homes panel
is ~28 years old and is almost as good as the day it was intalled, a GE
Are you replacing with an exact brand? GE for GE, SQD for SQD etc. I know
some manufactures make "universal replacements" I do not recommend them nor
do I use them.
I also will not use "thin breakers" on kitchen or appliance circuits. Just
my way of doing things.
The places where the bussing is singed/melted is not a good place to install
breakers. Move the breaker to another space in the panel and purchase a
blank cover for the space not used.
Check the panel and see if you can move the breakers around inside to get
away from the damaged places.
You might want to measure the load on the circuit that your having trouble
with. During no load and with the dishwasher running. I suggest that you
use the "no heat" setting for until you get this corrected.
If the circuit breaker doesn't make good contact with the panel buss, the
breaker will burn like you describe. If the buss metal has become annealed,
it will no longer conduct properly and the panel must be replaced
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.