With asphalt roofing shingles what is the difference between a 20 year
shingle and a 40 year shingle? I assume the 40 year are thicker and made
with better materials and also more expensive.
Why would I opt for the 40 year over the 20 year? I need a new roof but
can't justify spending the extra $ for the 40 year shingles.
Well, how many years left on the mortgage, and how old are you? :^/
But seriously, most of the cost of a re-roof is labor. If you plan on moving
in a few years, the fancy shingles will not pay back on sale. But if this is
your 'forever' house, who wants to pay the labor cost and suffer the
disruption more often than necessary ?
The plan is to stay in the house for 10 - 20 years, max.
Also, as I live in NY I want to be able to strike a balance on color to
hopefully reflect some of the summer sun rays to lower the temperature in
the attic but also be able to absorbe some of those rays in the winter
months. My house is white with an almost white/gray color now.
Thoughts on color selection? Other than personal preference does the color
make a difference on roof shingle life too?
Well, the main difference, besides your correct assumptions, (except for the
"better materials", just more of 'em) is: Twice the warrantee. In your area,
the color makes virtually no difference to the roof's longevity. In NY, I'd go
for the darker shingle. As long as she doesn't mind. But if 10/20 years is all
you plan to stay, maybe just save your money with the 20 yr. shingle. Tom
Someday, it'll all be over....
Good point. Few people stay in a house for 20 years. Some people own
the same house for a long time but, the average time between moves is
about 5 years the last I saw numbers. However, 40-year shingles are
probably the 3D contour style and you may just like the looks. Also,
if you will be there for a while (not 40 years) the higher eye appeal
may help the resale (or so the makers claim).
And you'd likely be wrong.
In many cases, the material is the same. Some of the extra money is put in a
pool to pay the few claims that will come in from people that 1) remember the
length of the warranty, 2) are still living in the same home 40 years later, 3)
saved the required documentation and 4) can prove that the material was
installed properly and 5) can be bothered to try to make it through the claim
Then they discover that it's a pro-rate warranty on material only and they get a
2/40th credit of the price from 38 years ago towards the list price of a current
The rest of the money is used to finance the product supplier's vacation to
Europe every year.
I had my roof replaced with 30 year, 5 tab architectural shingles.
They are a major pain to keep clean, as are all asphalt shingles. If I
had it to do over again I'd install a roof made of one of the newer
composite materials (avoid metal - it dents, and is noisy in
10-20 years is a long time to be looking at and maintaining the roof
you install. For not much more money than asphalt, you can have a
totally worry free roof that can easily be cleaned without voiding the
warranty (The warranty on every major brand of asphalt shingles I
looked at stated that evidence of power washing, and even the slight
indentation made by simply walking on the roof voids the warranty.)
If you spend an extra grand or so now, you won't miss the money in the
future, and you'll have a roof that looks great and is easy to take
My 2 cents.
On Sat, 5 Jun 2004 18:14:11 +0000 (UTC), firstname.lastname@example.org
(D. Gerasimatos) wrote:
Here's a few links I found to help you start your research. The exact
materials vary, but the roofs are mainly made of recycled plastic and
rubber compounds. The pricing is generally competative with 30 year
Check the 8/2003 Consumer Reports for durability ratings. There isn't
a strong relationship between quality and price or warranty.
Warranties for the shingles themselves and labor usually differ. But
whatever you get, insist on a UL class A fire resistance rating
because the homes that don't burn up in forrest fires have that
(that's not to say that class A guarantees surviving a fire, but class
B or C guarantees that the house burns down).
Ed, a $10,000 roof job would get laughed at by the realtors. I mean, that'd
better be a BIG roof. Besides, what if he leaves in 10 years? $5,000 off for a
new roof? Money in his hands now may be just the thing. Tom
Someday, it'll all be over....
I'm not sure what shingles you're referring to as 20/40 year
guaranteed shingles. But I'll tell you a personal experience between
the 3 tab and architectural shingles.
A year ago we had a pretty bad hail storm. *All* the roofs with 3 tab
shingles were damaged to the point of needed replacement, whereas the
architectural shingled roofs had very little damage. This year we had
another hail storm with the exact same results. The 3 tab roofs that
were less than a year old needed replacement again. That tells you the
added durability of architectural shingles. While higher priced with
additional years guarantee, they proved to be worth the extra money.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.