I opened my pool last week and went to get my pool water tested today. I did not believe the results so I went right home got 2 more samples and went to 2 other pool places to see what they thought.
My Pool - 23,000gal Gunite/Plaster
Here are the results:
Before I went I took my own tests: Total Chlor: 3 Free Chlor: 3 pH: 7.4 Alkalinity: 80
==============
1st place I went: Saturation index: -1.5 TDS: 670 CYA: 99 Total Chlor: 1.4 Free Chlor: 1.4 pH: 6.8 Demand Drops: 10 Tot. Alkalinity: 56 Adj. Alkalinity: 26 Hardness: 146They took the test and said your alkalinity is 26 you need to add 50lb of alkalinity up. Since I had just tested my self I did not believe the results. Besides this being low the wanted me to bring it up to 125 minimum. This is strange to me too as I have always been told 80-120 for my plaster pool. I questioned them and they stuck to their guns. After I left I noticed on the sheet they had something called Adjusted Alkalinity which is much lower than Alkalinity - I don't know where this adjusted value comes from but it was too late to ask. They use a system called "alex" by Bioguard.
============
2nd Place I went: Total Chlor: 3.0 Free Chlor: 3.0 pH: 7.2 Total Alkalinity: 80 Total Hardness: 250 CYA: 50They said my water was perfect - don't do a thing. They agreed that the alk should be in the 80-120 range.
============
3rd place I went: Total Chlor: 2.0 Free Chlor: 2.0 pH: 7.6 Total Alkalinity: 90 Total Hardness: 170 CYA: 40My own results seem to be more in line with the last two places. How could there be such a difference in opinion on pH, Alkalinity, CYA, and hardness?
Does the first place not know what they are doing or do they know something that the other do not know? I'm leaning tword the former.
Let me know what you think.
Regards