Hard Brexit: the eye-catching contingency plans to stop NI power blackouts
Thousands of electricity generators would have to be requisitioned
at short notice and put on barges in the Irish Sea to help keep
the lights on in Northern Ireland in the event of the hardest
no-deal Brexit, according to one paper drawn up by Whitehall
(If this URL takes you somewhere other than the article it took me too, I
suggest you refer your whining to the FT and not to me.)
Today is Boomtime, the 46th day of Confusion in the YOLD 3184
~ Stercus accidit ~
If you think that the Irish grid - which spans two nations - wont
contiunue to work after Brexit your are more lunhatic than I thought
These people seem to think a state of war will exist between the UK and
Hmm. Maybe that is the EUs last hope ...
Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the
gospel of envy.
Oh dear ! It looks like somebody has been watching Emily Maitless
First there was this
( "The Day Today". Australia and England are induced into declaring
war following robust questioning of their spokesmen by Chris Morris)
And then I swear I watched Maitless almost bring Israel and the
Palestinians to the brink of war during an interview with their
respective spokesmen which would have been on "Newsnight", I
assume. Now she's got the IRA on the move.
Anyway what Turnip, characteristically fails to appreciate is that
without an agreement in place which has been endorsed by all 27 EU
members, the Southern Irish as members of the EU will be forbidden,
as a condition of their continuing membership, from trading electricity
with the non EU member in the North. To ensure compliance if necessary
the relevant connections will have to be physically disconnected if
It really is as simple as that.
It looks like we may have to start importing generators too.
Providing we can get the petrol.
Unfortunately, unlike with Northern Ireland there's never been
any history of smuggling petrol over the border from France.
Charles is alluding to the fact that the current arrangement
between the UK and France is the result of our both being
members of the EU. But when one of us leaves the EU, then that
arrangement will no longer apply.
The arrangement whereby any EU member state, Germany in this case
can buy Gas from Russia is the result of an agreement between
the EU as a whole and Russia.
This does howver raise the question as to how the UK is going to
import any energy at all, in the event of a hard Brexit.
Maybe up North in some places they've still got some slag heaps
where they can fish out the odd lumps of coal, taking them home
in the pram as they did in the 30's. ( Thats the 1930's for any
younger viewers )
Being stupid and ignorant already puts you at a considerable disadvantage.
Being stupid, ignorant and embittered, owing to your isolation, whereby
you're reduced to posting on a NewsGroup based in a country 9000 miles
away, of which you clearly know very little, puts you at an even greater
Being stupid, ignorant, and embittered and posting whilst being drunk,
in your case at least is clearly inadvisable; to say the very least
While the news probably never made the front page of The Didgeeredoo Post
and Argus, the reason we're in this mess is precisely because as members
of the EU we've not been allowed to negotiate trade deals of our own.
Otherwise they'd already be in place to be implemented in the event
of Brexit. And what applies to us prior to Brexit, will apply equally
well to France after Brexit. If they want to stay members at least.
I'm sure if you go outside right now and stagger about for long
enough you might be lucky enough to find a sheep who will let
you take your mind off things. At least until you sober up.
<reams of your puerile shit any 2 year old could leave for dead flushed
where it belongs>
There is no mess, just immense piles of lies by remoaners.
They arent allowed to negotiate trade AGREEMENTS
on their own. They are however free to negotiate
individual trade deals with operations outside the EU.
And free to continue individual trade agreements entered
into within the EU when one of the partys leaves the EU.
They don’t get kicked out of the EU if they choose to continue
a specific trade agreement after one of the partys leaves the EU.
Even you should realise that if Britain does a hard brexit, Airbus
will continue to buy RR engines from Britain even tho it is outside
the EU, because if they don’t do that, Airbus is dead because even
you should have noticed that aircraft do need engines.
Is it an arrangement between two commercial privately owned companies
and bugger all to do with the EU? The cost of the energy flowing may
change due to import or export tariffs but the energy will still flow.
The cost differential will be no different to the National Grid buying
from differently costed sources depending on demand. Even with an
extortionate tariff French electricity may be cheaper than that from our
own Green sources.
Maybe all that will happen is that all the electrons will have to be
stored in a large warehouse until the overworked customers inspectors
have had time to check the contents? If they time the delay correctly in
checking it could be used to fill the gaps in energy flow from the welsh
just one actually, and I THINK its National Grid for the French ICT.
Oh, Its joint owned
"Ownership is shared between National Grid Interconnectors Limited
(NGIC) and Réseau de Transport d’Electricité (RTE, French Transmission
Britned run the Dutch Interconnect.
"BritNed Development Limited is a joint venture of Dutch TSO TenneT and
British National Grid and operates the electricity link between Great
Britain and the Netherlands which was commissioned in 2011."
The two links to 'Le continent' are a bit like the Darford
tinnel/bridge, except te guvmints never annexed them.
A private company takes a cut to transmit energy from one side or the
other so e.g. if EON (UK) need to buy some gigawatt hours from EDF in
france, to satisfy its customners, it will enter into a contract with
the cable company and pay them a percentage to get them across the channnel.
Likewise if EON in germanny is short of GWH it will enter into a
contract with say DRAX to buy some leccy, and pay transit to the cable
If the two flows cancel out the cable company gets paid double for
Ther is nothing political about any of this UNLESS the EU choose to
stick tarriffs on electricity imports.
Its a simple case of mutlinational subisidiaries owned by parent
companies that are inside and outside the EU.
In the case of Ireland the situation is this (sorry remeaners, I know
you dislike facts, but tough shit)
Since 2006, EirGrid has operated and developed the national high voltage
electricity grid in Ireland. EirGrid is a state-owned company. EirGrid
is independent from ESB. We operate the flow of power on the grid and
plan for its future, while ESB networks is responsible for carrying out
maintenance, repairs and construction on the grid. The grid moves
wholesale power around the country. We bring energy from generation
stations to heavy industry and high-tech users. We also supply the
distribution network operated by ESB Networks that powers every
electricity customer in the country.
SONI is the electricity System Operator for Northern Ireland. From our
control centre in Belfast, we ensure that power flows where and when
needed. We bring power from those who generate energy, and supply the
distribution network operated by Northern Ireland Electricity that
brings power to individual homes, farms and businesses. SONI is
independent from Northern Ireland Electricity. Since 2014, SONI is
responsible for planning for the future of the grid, while Northern
Ireland Electricity is responsible for maintenance, repairs and
construction of the grid.
SEMO is the Single Electricity Market Operator for the island of
Ireland. This organisation runs the wholesale market for electricity.
This allows companies to make bids to buy or sell electricity in bulk. A
well-run electricity market is essential for all those who need this
energy. It provides fair and independent pricing for those who generate
electricity. It also permits competition in the sale of power, which
benefits every electricity user.
So the national grid equivalent of Nothern Ireland is a wholly owned
subsidiary of an Irish Repllic based company.
Again no reason for it to be an issue *unless te EU makes it one*. And
tells Eirgrid to shut down SONI and SEMO, and isolate NI.
Which would be enough reason to declare war on te EU.
And enlist NATO and US support to invade Brussels.
This is the real point. Any moves the EU makes to damge the UK will
result in as much or more damage to the countries and businesses that
comprise the EU..
Those businesses dont particularly want change, because change costs a
little. But they most certainly do not want, post a hard brexit, the EU
making the changes any worse than they need to be bu engaging in trade
embargos, spiteful political interference in electricity markets or air
If they do that, the weight of the Eurobusiness community would swing
from Europhile to Eurosceptic in a blink.
Trump has more or less stated (though whether his words carry any weight
remeians to be seen) that he would utterly support the UK against a
The US, like it or not, swings a lot of weight.
The cost of the energy flowing may
Certainly would be, but of course one of the delights of Brexit is taht
te climate change acat, te CfD mecahnism, the xcpacaity agreemens and
the like cpoiuld all be tiorn upo, reneable obligations scrapped, and we
could, given Trump style leadership, go back to selecting technologies
that work on a cost basis.
There ares some interesting hints in a statement by parliamentary
under-secretary of state at BEIS (wot replaced DECC) abour the UK
reglarory authority (that is well on the way to decoupling itself from
Euratom), that it will not necessarily be copying Euratom rules and
procedures, but only creating an *equivalent* safety standard'...
"Although we will be leaving Euratom, we remain firmly committed to the
highest standards of nuclear safeguards and non-proliferation. The draft
Nuclear Safeguards Regulations set out in this consultation are a
concrete demonstration of this commitment. They will establish a new
domestic safeguards regime for the UK that will provide coverage and
effectiveness equivalent to that currently provided by Euratom and are
the means by which we will exceed our international obligations."
I wonder how it all works with switzerland then
That's a power house of nuclear and hydro power.
Norway, used to balance Denmark and German renewable shit, isn't in the
And as you pointed out, neither is Russia.
If we are going to have trade embarhgoes on energy, or impose
tarrigfs...welll look here
"Since 2012, when Russia joined the WTO, EU-Russia trade relations have
also been framed by WTO rules."
What that means AIUI is that the EU has *de jure* committed to applying
no worse terms to Britain under a hard brexit scenario, in terms of
imports and exports, than it does to Russia.
Breach of WTO rules could lead to sanctions being imposed on the EU by
Russia and the rest of the world,
Project Fear is scraping the barrel for any legal agreement that exists
under current EU rules and claiming that post brexit it will cease to
exist and therefore trade will stop.
Its all bluff, unless the EU intends to become an internationall rogue
But tjis is te quandary te EU is in., Its an emperors new clothes moment.
The little boy Farage has pointed and said 'but what does the EU
And the truth is dawning, that it does nothing except protect lazy
incompetent businesses in Europe, from international competition. And
that it has no interest in the people of Europe at all.
All the other stuff it does could just as easily - and a lot more
efficiently - be done by a series of bilateral or multilateral trade
agreements. Imagine another sort iof EU that said 'look chaps, we have
negotiated a package with canada, its up to you if you sign up for it,
or whether you go WTO or whether you do a deal yoursleves'.
Ditto for things like Euratom. What has politics got to do with an
international standards authority? Nothing, BUT its been politicised BY
THE EU, so off we go.
The EU is lie a new boss who comes in and knwos fuck all about the
business, but tries to worm its way in by making up rules.
Along with a fair percentage of remoaners, I have always been in favour
of some form of *co-operative* European authority that all nations could
feel *belonged to them*, as a way of improving relationships between
European nations and leveraging ecoomies of scale *where appropiate*.
What we have however is a *coercive* authority that considers that the
*nations belong to it*.
These are not public servants, they are a criminal mafia, a protection
racket that has not protected, who have usurped power from national
governments under false pretences. The UK has called their bluff and
shown them up for what they are.
If Britain leaves, the EU is finished.
Slow and thick as the average European is, the question has been asked
'what actually is the EU for?' and if the answer is 'nothing we couldn't
do better and cheaper ourselves by simply agreeing to among ourselves',
well its goodnight Vienna for the EU.
"When one man dies it's a tragedy. When thousands die it's statistics."
On Sat, 14 Jul 2018 11:40:27 +0100, "Dave Plowman (News)"
And for the Brexiteers next little argument against the UK having to
abide by the rules of others
Although it will be a while before the WTO gets around to factoring in
tax havens, so we will not be leaving that union in a hurry.
Really is funny when these 'sovereignty' Brexiteers complain of an EU
country breaking EU rules. But of course are very happy to see the likes
of Rees Mogg bend UK ones when it comes to paying taxes.
Quite understandable if all Brexiteers were as rich as Rees Mogg, but get
the impression many on here are poor as the proverbial church mouse.
Perhaps they think by supporting their betters they'll get a few crumbs
from the master's table?
*I have never hated a man enough to give his diamonds back.
Dave Plowman email@example.com London SW
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.