Wound Dressing for TREES

Wound Dressing was studied by mycologist, tree biologist, chemist and so forth by the US FOREST SERVICE researchers. Here at the bottom of the page is a publication titled WOUND DRESSINGS: RESULTS OF STUDIES OVER 13 YEARS in Journal of Arboriculture.

formatting link
majority of bombardment of negative criticism on this newsgroup comes from folk from Texas. The only place I know of in the world that it is a law that you must apply wound dressing is Texas. Texas folks gave Dr. Shigo a hard time about Modern Arboriculture. They are the only group of people that I know of that fought him tooth and nail. Who is Dr. Shigo? His profile is here:
formatting link
There are some good folk from Texas that I have personally studied tree biology with and dissected trees with. My critics do not dissect trees.

His material is here:

formatting link
Enjoy

My critics are primarily from Texas. They disagree with most of Modern Arboriculture treatments based on a thorough understanding of tree biology. Go figure. Don Staples, from Texas, is a practicing forester with communication problems with the researchers in tree biology. The story addressing the communication problem is here:

formatting link
a little background on the issue.

There is a time when wound dressing could be helpful. If you make a flush cut, like many oaks in Texas suffer from, and paint it with wound dressing. The wound dressing will stimulate the succession of micro organisms and speed up the rot process. This would give you a cavity. Not good for the individual but good for small wildlife that use cavities. In wildlife management I often make flush cuts in the woods for small wildlife. I rather not use the wound dressing.

If anybody has any data to state that through research, with controls, wound dressing has been proven to stop microorganisms or the succession of microorganisms, please email with the data. I would be happy to review it.

Reply to
symplastless
Loading thread data ...

Hey braino scrambolo, I'd put you up against Texas A & M any time any day. Nobody said apply wound dressing to flush cuts. Flush cuts went out with two decades ago of information. Keep up Scramby. I DO NOT MAKE FLUSH CUTS. NOBODY WITH HAVE A BRAIN AND ONE TOOTH DOES. Get over it already.

I'm a New Yorker, by the way. I just live in Texas.

Reply to
Jangchub

If anybody has any data, such as Texas A & M, to state that through research, with controls, wound dressing has been proven to stop microorganisms or the succession of microorganisms, please email with the data. I would be happy to review it

Reply to
symplastless

I have searched the statuets, yard man, and cannot find the "law" of which you speak. Please publish it for or edification. We do not give Shigo a hard time, we give you a hard time, you need to accept being what you are, a yard man. I would also like to see where Texans fought Shigo "tooth and nail", seems you take great importance in deffinitions, give us a definition of "fought him tooth and nail", while you are at it, give us your back ground and education that allows you to be call an arborist. And when, while I am at it, you are going to take the arborist test again.

I still need your attoruneys name, or we will have to file directly to the court, you can hold some of that embarrasment at bay by responding.

fought him tooth and nail.

Reply to
Don Staples

No, not email my friend. Public. They even mention your "man crush" in the paper.

formatting link

Reply to
Jangchub

Not enough colored pictures for him to become interested.

Reply to
Don Staples

I have a funny feeling he won't acknowledge this abstract. Probably if he does, it will be to say how wonderful Shigo methods are. Duh. The argument is not with Shigo, it's with the the wingnut.

Reply to
Jangchub

I think I have discovered why he will not answer, it is from a publication on Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, some things about which he has no idea.

Reply to
Sue Staples

Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, some things about which he has no idea.

And hey, it even mentions his boyfriend, Shigo. It took me exactly three seconds to do a search and about five minutes to read the abstract which proves why we paint fresh cuts in TX. It has nothing to do with incorrect pruninig, rather it suggests we use Shigo cuts which are proper. I don't know one arborist who doesn't know to cut outside the branch collar. Feh. This is such an incredible waste of time.

Reply to
Jangchub

I think I have discovered why he will not answer, it is from a publication on Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, some things about which he has no idea.

Reply to
symplastless

What is the control in the experiment?

Reply to
symplastless

urban forestry? please define what a forest is. What an ignorant dumb f*ck you are, yard man.

Reply to
D. Staples

Well, for once, some useful and interesting information emerged from from the pile of invectives and ad hominems.

Reply to
Billy

It's always been there. It will always be there. I didn't feel I had anything to prove. I supplied the abstract and he didn't even read it.

Om

Reply to
Jangchub

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.