I am now on my fourth replacement for two Arborvitae (Emerald Green), and the general pattern is that they grow for about one season and then start to die. These trees are on the West side of the house, but get at least a full half day of sun. They were planted correctly and well maintained with adequate water and Miracle Grow for evergreens. I'm beginning to suspect the nursery, although they claim that over the years, they have used several sources for trees. They usually come bailed, and we remove the wrapping for planting. There were formerly Red Cedars growing in these locations, one on either side of the house entrance, and they were mature trees when we moved in 20 years ago. We took out the Red Cedars about four years ago when they gave us problems with Apple Cedar Rust on our apple trees, but the cedars were always healthy looking, aside from the rust. It's a real puzzle why these trees keep dying. Since taking out the cedars, there are no signs of the Apple Cedar Rust.
Sherwin D.