Try them all - try a scroll saw. I would be very interested in seeing pictures of your first attempts, no matter which method you use.
To me, the trick is to use a high quality tool and not let it get dull past the point where it takes more than a Hard Arkansas Stone to put the edge back on it. An even better trick is to not have to use them very often
Can a novice keep one sharp? Sure, don't use it. Can a novice put the edge back on a dull one? Possibly/probably/maybe - try and see. Can a novice even use one effectively? Again, you won't know until you try.
Jerry O.