I've used them a few times. I was a little dissapointed that the 2 3/4" x 36 Oak legs were made up of laminated pieces vs furniture stock but I understand that 12/4 Oak is a bit hard to come by at a decent price. However, they had done a great job of matching the stock. It actually looked to be be book matched from 6/4. So each leg matched well and I really had to llok to see that they were laminated. Actually didn't notice until about half way through the build. The legs didn't all match but they were well within the typical range of Red Oak and I had board stock in the poiece that had just as much variance.
The Pine versions of the same legs were from a single piece of stock.
The sanding could have been a bit better, but was pretty good. They had obviously only sanded on the lathe so there were light cross grain marks that I had to hand sand out.
I would say I consider them a good vendor. I assume if I was really worried about color matcvhing they would probably be one of the few people with enough stock on hand (for the price) to provide a matched set.
I asked a local guy that was pitching me for some of my turning work to price out the Oak legs for me and he couldn't touch it and he has zero overhead.
I will continue to use them.