Being cheap and/or sloppy is the same as thrifty or frugal...
I'm w/ Chuck on this one...the generation which survived the Depression has a whole different understanding of "need" than current ones. I, for one, am grateful that my grandfather keep so much -- now, while some of it is, in fact, not valuable, other things are fond remembrances. Plus, all the old lumber salvaged from the old chicken coop or other places and stored in the haymow for 60 years or more came in handy in the barn restoration. Not easy to find full-dimension 2x stuff anymore...