Funny this question comes up now, Not more than an hour ago I had the same
problem, woodwork in bedroom that is more than 40 years old. the frames
around the windows are great but the moulding is all crapped up with various
layers of paints and holes. I took an original piece to Lowes and the girl
there matched it perfectly with an olympic stain.
Damn good thing, cause I didn't want to off shade too badly and I sure
didn't want to replace all the woodwork.