If you are filling a bath, yes. But people here are saying that the output of a 24kW combi is totally inadequate from which one might infer that they are looking for the equivalent of twice this. If I can do the sums, 1kW delivers 858 litre-degrees per hour. Assume water coming in at 5C and out at 42C, 37C rise so
1kW delivers 23 litres per hour, 48kW 1110 litres/hour or 18.5 litres per minute. Even if you have your 75 litre cylinder at (say) 65C (which then means that a condensing boiler is being run below max efficiency) after about 6 minutes your stored hot water is gone and the maximum delivery will depend on (a) the boiler output; and (b) the ability of the cylinder coil to transfer the heat.
So get this shower performance in an average house you either need a very large cylinder or a grossly oversized (for most houses) boiler. Unless I'm missing something .....
Also remember that if the cylinder is within the body of the house, this heat isn't totally wasted during the times of the year where heating is needed.
What you have to remember is John lives in a world where baths are half the normal size that people would choose, and showers are more than adequate at dog pee flow and temperature. He also lives in a world where better than 100% efficiency is the norm, and sees no contradiction in that term.
If you look further, he always quotes maker's advertising as backup to his views. Others measure their usage and quote from experience.
If a 75 litre cylinder is exhausted after 6 mins a boiler and quick recovery coil can replenish at 10 litres min while being emptied. So in that 6 mins @ 60 litres plus 75 litres. So that means a normal bath will be filled no problem. It is not a matter of debate. It just happens.
I think you lost the thread a little. I gave an example of the know-it-alls giving bad advise re: downsizing cylinders. Paul Barker says as 24Kw combi is more than fine for a shower.
Grossly oversized boiler? We are coming to the one size fits all, around
24kW, using modulation. Aks anyone who has a combi in a flat. The rads are hot within a few minutes, a great bonus, then it throttles back. You can get a combi for £350 and not use the DHW section. Ravenheat encourage this. Many installers do this as combi's are cost effective due to mass take up and manufacturing.
_________________________________________ Usenet Zone Free Binaries Usenet Server More than 120,000 groups Unlimited download
........at it again he is.....yes he is nice people....If the cylinder cupboard is below the loft much of the heat goes into the loft....obvious we all know...but DIYing caber making is a very different task...
_________________________________________ Usenet Zone Free Binaries Usenet Server More than 120,000 groups Unlimited download
I'm not arguing re baths. *If* you are of the view that a proper shower needs 18 or so litres per minute (q.v. an ordinary combi is totally unequal to the task: not my personal view) then you need to be able to reheat water at this rate or have enough storage. On your numbers said shower will start running cold after 8-9 minutes.
HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.