redwood vs pressure treated fence posts

Ask HomeOwners' Hub community your home or garden question

Threaded View
We need to replace our redwood fences. One neighbor claims that untreated
redwood is more rot reistant than treated wood.

Can anyone tell me what fence post is more resistant to rot and insects:
pressure treated posts or untreated redwood?

Is the brown pressure treated wood better than the green treated wood?

Is there some website that you can direct me to that shows this information.

thanks in advance



Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts


buffalo ny: this may save you some money. this may depend on your
climate, soil moisture, and drainage travel. easiest answer sometimes
comes from the permit office or local fence company. careful of the
type of pressure treating it may be limited in your area regarding
kids and pets. you may need to check your survey for placement, and
your town for limits and right-of-ways. regardless of how long your
fence has been around, fences are often excluded from front yards,
intersections, and even some neighborhoods by zoning. since life and
cost per year are probably concerns, you'll want to read more at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wood_preservation

Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts


You want a rot-resistant post?

Steel posts in a concrete base with wood 4x4 bolted to the post.



Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts


In my area the CCA green treated wihich I dont think is made anymore
is fine after 30 years, redwood would have lasted 10, I never saw
brown treated

Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts


I assume by brown you mean creosote treated.  I've never seen fence
material treated with that.  Plus it's very toxic for yard use.
(Creosote is now a restricted use pesticide).  That leaves the green
(ACQ) treated wood, redwood, or cypress.
If you live in the NW, redwood may be an option but the last time I
inquired at my local lumber yards I was told "no one stocks it
anymore, and if ordered be prepared to pay VERY high prices."
If it were me, I'd use treated 4x4's and cypress boards/panels.

KC

Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts


  Answers to some of your questions depend, in part, upon where the
fence posts are locate.

Are the in southern Louisiana, Mississippi or Alabama, Florida?

Are the posts in Alaska?  High desert country in the Great Basin?

All different sets of bugs, different precipitation and ground water issues,
  different teperrature cycles and different freeze / thaw issues
regarding ground water.

Also, of course different soil types with different watrer retention issues.

All of these have a bearing on wood post longevity.

Can you tell us more about the climate, soil type and geographical
location?

Universaly, the plastic / ? PVC ? posts will hold up well, but it
doesn't sound
like that will fit in with your CC&Rs.

Thanks.

Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts



If you can get it, plain locust heartwood will last 50 years :0

Free men own guns - www(dot)geocities(dot)com/CapitolHill/5357/

Re: redwood vs pressure treated fence posts

...


black locust, that is...

So will Osage orange...

--

Site Timeline