They bully a grandmother!!!!
I wrote the school directly here:
http://www.greece.k12.ny.us/contact.cfm?school=7 and I was sure to check
these boxes: Athena Middle School, Greece Central School District, Business
Office, Districtwide, Energy Management, Family Support Center, Mailroom,
Support Services, Community Education
A snippet, though I am not a wordsmith by any means, feel free to cut and
"Something needs to be done about this, immediately. The children's parents
need to be notified of such behavior and an appropriate punishment needs to
be determined and executed.
This video IS going to gain mainstream media attention. I suggest the
school and it's authorities take an immediate, strong stance on bullying
before anything gets misconstrued. This topic has been heavily covered in
recent years by the media and you would do well by this poor woman to stand
up for her rights and give her the justice she deserves."
I'd have said unbehaved, and hostile. Clearly, the kids were out of control.
And, if I'd been that monitor, I'd have pounded a couple of the kids for
TinyURL was created!
The following URL:
has a length of 189 characters and resulted in the following TinyURL which
has a length of 26 characters:
[Open in new window]
Govt is partially to blame. Too many do gooders preventing parents
from properly disciplining their children. The other problem is
pompous parents allowing their kids to believe no adult can touch
them. I recall when I, and several other parents, hadda stop two
policemen from hauling off a working single mother after she did no
more than give her daughter a thoroughly deserved spanking --not
beating, bludgening, or other form of physical abuse-- for leaving
home and wandering off downtown, 5 blocks away. The kid knew the
rules and was old enough to know she did wrong.
Kids are more than aware of the sanctions against adults. I had a 6
yr old kid, who was tormenting my 5 yr old daughter, look me square in
the eye and tell me, "You touch me and you'll be in jail in 5
minutes"! I was stunned. This was not much later than the policemen
and the mother incident. Instead, I went to the kids father and told
him to reign in his kid or I was gonna kick his ass (the father ass).
Still, kids have little or no respect for adults, these days. You
can't expect the school, where you dump yer kid fer 5-7 hrs, to
maintain any sort of discipline if you tell the school you'll sue the
shit outta them if they lay a hand on yer kid.
Kids are the out of control monsters only because we, as a supposedly
enlightened society, have allowed them to be. They must be taught
there are consequences to their actions and they WILL be held
responsible. A simple five across the eyes will set the tone and
deliver the message. ;)
For sure. They are wasting tax money paying with this bus monitor that
has no control over the kids. In fact she's not even watching the
kids, just sitting there and crying. She should be fired and a
responsible person that can take control should be hired. Do they put
up with that behavior in the classroom? Why then on the bus.
BTW here there are no bus monitors. But there is a video camera. If
the driver has a problem, the culprit is on video and corrective
action is taken the next day. From detention to banning from the bus.
When parents have to drive their kid to school for a week the problem
is usually solved...
The value of bus monitors becomes apparent instantly when young children are
involved. One starts crying (maybe for no apparent reason) and then the
others join in. At that point, only a "mother" will do to settle things
down and keep the driver from going nuts.
The woman was bullied. That's wrong.
Not sure what the job description of a bus monitor is in that
jurisdiction, but my understanding of a monitor is to keep order so
that the bus driver can concentrate on driving and not be distracted.
If that poor grandma was bullied by grade school kids then IMO she is
not qualified for that job. Further her inability to do her job is
dangerous since it does allow the driver to be distracted...
Did you really watch the same video I did? Touching the quivering
grandma was an assault? A 7th grader's bravado was a credible threat??
Give me a break. That situation could easily be cleaned up with the
proper discipline (and not some of the ridiculous things suggested
Hopefully nothing. The PD should not even be involved in such a petty
situation. This is a school responsibility. I'd start with hiring a
qualified monitor, post the rules with penalties, and stick to it.
Most of the parents I know would take care of it pronto. Likely they
had no idea what was going on. And if they don't want to cooperate, as
I said stick to the rules/dicipline. My suggestion: Warning>school
detention>banned from bus>banned from school.
and here we have the real problem...the kids are such a PITA that a monitor has
to protect the driver. Put cameras in the bus, any kid that distracts the driver
gets one warning and then no more bus rides for him/her. simple, cost effective
and ultimately safer for all concerned
Anybody remember TV news of 6 y/o being cuffed by police for assaulting
a teacher? Don't blame the victim....if she is a monitor, that may be
her only authority until she can report offenses. Driver has a radio?
Stop the bus? Then we have 30 parents calling up the school to complain
about their kid being late. Any word of police involvement where this
happened? I'm sure it isn't over yet.
No one has the authority or ability to do anything these days. We had
no bus monitors in the past, the driver would just yell at a kid and
that would end it.
When I was in high school, (in Philly in the 1960's) they had public
transportation buses waiting for us. Sometimes the guys on the back
of the bus would smoke. This was a packed bus, standing in the aisle.
The driver just drove to the end of his route, no stops along the way.
At the end of his route he opened the door and walked off.
We knew what the problem was, we had to now find our own way home. No
parents complained or whined that Johnny was punished. It worked with
not a word spoken. Today, there would be law suites, protests, parent
marching, police, kids traumatized and in need of therapy, etc.
I never have understood the mind of a superintendent. One of the area
schools had a senior prank where they got a key from one of the parents
(who was a school board member) and went in decorated the school in Post
it notes. These people (and the janitor who was working at the time)
were summarily suspended (the janitor was fired). But hey, they can't do
anything about bullying or this kind of shit on the bus?
America is at that awkward stage. It's too late
to work within the system, but too early to shoot
I read about that....the artwork, done all in post-it notes, was darn
creative. Still can't believe a school board member let the kids into
the school after hours. Feel sorry for the janitor, who thought the
artwork rather impressive....tell a school board member to get out of
the school or stand and watch.
In a school district where the miscreants use guns and knives often,
then some offensive language is probably a "good day" :o)
From what I've been hearing, the monitor did none of the things to defend
herself, or restore order. I've also heard that she is declining to press
charges. Makes me wonder if someone "tested his limits" and found out she's
a push over. And, so they pressed harder and harder until this incident?
Christopher A. Young
Learn more about Jesus
Agree with you. I said similar in another post. The kids
are dispicable, need to be punished and should be
banned from the bus for some period. But the whole
purpose of a monitor is to keep order on the bus.
I did not see any attempt to assert order on the bus.
Where was the , "Sit down. One more word out of you and this
bus is going back to the school where your parents
will pick you up in the principal's office!"
Another option if she couldn't control them would be
to have the bus driver proceed to the nearest police
station, or call police on a cell phone. If she can't
handle rude kids, what good would she be in a real
On Sat, 23 Jun 2012 06:19:18 -0700 (PDT), " firstname.lastname@example.org"
Police needed for simple school discipline? Except for "real" criminal
activity: Guns, knives, drugs ect. why bother the police? If the
school administration (and individual employees) can't handle the kids
on their own they should be replaced with someone who can...
On Sat, 23 Jun 2012 12:51:19 -0400, " email@example.com"
The 'assault' in this case involved *lightly touching* a school bus
monitor. A simple stern "stop that' from the monitor would have
stopped it. Then the prescribed punishment for the unwanted touching
of a school employee should have been employed to stop future
violations and to deter others. Instead she just sat there and cried
not even acknowledging the touch. A very sad monitor indeed.
(Well, maybe not so sad as she is now apparently a very rich woman.)
Yes there are times police are needed for a school assault report.
Examples might be punching a teacher or a serious injury to a student.
But I would estimate that there are many crimes committed on the
school grounds every day from stealing lunch money to minor student
assaults that are much better handled by the school administration.
Yeah, if it was only one kid I might agree with you, but it wasn't.
BTW: Assault can also include violent verbal attacks, which this may
have qualified for. You don't have to hit someone to assault them.
America is at that awkward stage. It's too late
to work within the system, but too early to shoot
And he conveniently forgets that one of the kids also
said something about her being so fat that he could
stick her with a knife like butter. Is that worthy of
conviction for making a terroristic threat? No.
But together with the other behavior, since the
bus aid obviously was incapable of handling it,
it was enough to justify either taking the bus back to
school, or to the police or calling the police to the bus, if they
refused to stop. And if this was done just once,
imagine the effect when all the rest of the similar
kids find out what happened.
Imagine what these people would be saying if
the incident continued, distracted the driver, and
there was a fatal accident. Or if the thugs
continued, turning their attention on some other
student, and seriously injuring them.
On Sat, 23 Jun 2012 12:17:07 -0700 (PDT), " firstname.lastname@example.org"
The kid was commenting on her fat (no wonder), not threatening her
with an upcoming stabbing. Even kids use non-literal descriptions in
their language. Ever told someone you would kill them in casual
conversation? Did you? Did they call the cops on you??
Punish *all* the kids, even the non-participants? Wouldn't it be
better just to punish just the bad ones individually? Wouldn't it be
even better if the situation didn't occur in the first place because a
competent bus monitor had that route under control?
Exactly. If the school had control, the situation would not have
happened. You don't really think this situation happened for the very
first time the kid decided to record it do you...
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.