The house was built new in 1983 and I've replaced the button for the front doorbell a couple of times over the years. It was an unlighted button originally and I've always replaced it with an unlighted button. This time I haven't been able to find an unlighted button so I bought one that lights. When I attach the second wire, the doorbell begins ringing and doesn't stop until I remove the second wire. I thought the first replacement button was bad so I bought another, also lighted, and the same thing happens. Back doorbell was replaced with an unlighted button a few years ago and still works fine.
I've found an online source for an unlighted replacement pushbutton but is that my problem? Any insight would be appreciated.