My chimney has reached the end of its life. The mortar has turned to sand and the chimney needs to be rebuilt through the upper floor, the attic, and over the roof. A mason quoted me $3k, plus I will have to refinish a bedroom wall and patch the roof. Since I was going to replace the heating system (now I have single-pipe steam) I am considering buying a directly vented furnace and water heater and do away with the chimney. I would gain quite a bit of space in two rooms and a chase to run piping and wiring upstairs.
Would you consider this "remuddling"? One of my neighbors was shocked by this idea and said that a 100 year old colonial would look just stupid without a chimney. It is an internal chimney and only the 4 ft above the roof is visible. It is not a structural element.
EJ