I have both, a 1950 freeezer now used as clothes storage and new stuff. I have used a KAW meter on Both and I am right as www.EnergyStar.G= ov will confirm. Its BS to state " you save little" , if you want to waste energy go ahead , be a hog, my neighbor keeps 1500w of incandesants on 24x7, but its not apropriate to do so in this day and age, and its a waste of $$. So the rich dont give a shit.