I placed a Waterfurnace Geo. system in my house - in June 2008. It
was 2 systems - a 2 ton unit and a 4 ton unit. (3600+ sq ft. house) -
the A/C cost went down from approx. $400 month to $100 month and the
heating bill has been around $150/month. The previous propane costs
were around $5500 per year. I researched for approx. 3 years and
never could find straight numbers on the savings. The A/C is awesome
and the heat is almost too hot - recommend getting a humidifier w/ the
system. I paid approx. $28k for both sys. installed. So, essentially
i will pay less then $1000 to heat AND cool my house. A big
difference from the 5-6k i spent last year.
was 2 systems - a 2 ton unit and a 4 ton unit. (3600+ sq ft. house) -
the A/C cost went down from approx. $400 month to $100 month and the
heating bill has been around $150/month. The previous propane costs
were around $5500 per year. I researched for approx. 3 years and
never could find straight numbers on the savings. The A/C is awesome
and the heat is almost too hot - recommend getting a humidifier w/ the
system. I paid approx. $28k for both sys. installed. So, essentially
i will pay less then $1000 to heat AND cool my house. A big
difference from the 5-6k i spent last year.
pewty@comcast.net wrote:

I don't understand why not. I installed a WaterFurnace system in early
90's -- the WaterFurnace sizing calculations and estimates of heat and
cooling loads were almost identical to the actual performance as well as
the data from the Oklahoma State geothermal research group and TVA were
quite accurate as to energy efficiencies and comparative inputs relative
to conventional systems. That was almost 20 years ago--can't imagine
they're not at least as good now.
BTW, I'm not the least surprised by your experience...
--
I don't understand why not. I installed a WaterFurnace system in early
90's -- the WaterFurnace sizing calculations and estimates of heat and
cooling loads were almost identical to the actual performance as well as
the data from the Oklahoma State geothermal research group and TVA were
quite accurate as to energy efficiencies and comparative inputs relative
to conventional systems. That was almost 20 years ago--can't imagine
they're not at least as good now.
BTW, I'm not the least surprised by your experience...
--
Yea, and you paid about 20k more than the two conventional systems cost.
They will last maybe 10 years if you are lucky. Servicing them will be far
more expensive. So tell me again what you saved.

They will last maybe 10 years if you are lucky. Servicing them will be far
more expensive. So tell me again what you saved.
jamesgangnc wrote:

I can't judge what his installed cost would have been for a conventional
system.
I will say my experience has been the system has been in place
approaching 20 years so far and is still working w/ no major maintenance
costs to date.
It's been long enough I can't even recall what the trenching costs were
but I'm quite certain it has recouped its additional costs as compared
to conventional (gas wasn't available at the location at the time which
was a major decision factor, of course).
I won't say they're the solution for everybody but I will say they're
well worth consideration.
--
I can't judge what his installed cost would have been for a conventional
system.
I will say my experience has been the system has been in place
approaching 20 years so far and is still working w/ no major maintenance
costs to date.
It's been long enough I can't even recall what the trenching costs were
but I'm quite certain it has recouped its additional costs as compared
to conventional (gas wasn't available at the location at the time which
was a major decision factor, of course).
I won't say they're the solution for everybody but I will say they're
well worth consideration.
--
This Thread
- Geothermal
- 01-23-2009
| pewty | 01-23-2009 |
| jamesgangnc | 01-25-2009 |
| jamesgangnc | 01-27-2009 |
| jamesgangnc | 01-28-2009 |
| philipa01 | 01-28-2009 |
| jamesgangnc | 01-28-2009 |
| Twice Retired | 01-29-2009 |
Please Register and login to reply and use other advanced options
- Humidifying with Geothermal
- Home Repair
- 2009-02-05
- Geothermal heat pumps ?
- Home Repair
- 2009-02-04
- Geothermal system and sinkholes
- HVAC Discussions
- 2009-05-13
- N. Texas Geothermal Install
- HVAC Discussions
- 2010-07-16
- Geothermal and new vents
- HVAC Discussions
- 2007-10-30
- Adding Water to Geothermal Loop
- Home Repair
- 2008-03-13
- geothermal runs constantly
- HVAC Discussions
- 2008-11-24
- geothermal heat pump insufficient
- Home Repair
- 2006-09-09
- GeoThermal unit in Ohio?
- HVAC Discussions
- 2008-08-12
> was 2 systems - a 2 ton unit and a 4 ton unit. (3600+ sq ft. house) -
> the A/C cost went down from approx. $400 month to $100 month and the
> heating bill has been around $150/month. The previous propane costs
> were around $5500 per year. I researched for approx. 3 years and
> never could find straight numbers on the savings. The A/C is awesome
> and the heat is almost too hot - recommend getting a humidifier w/ the
> system. I paid approx. $28k for both sys. installed. So, essentially
> i will pay less then $1000 to heat AND cool my house. A big
> difference from the 5-6k i spent last year.